The United Nations is picking its next secretary-general, and the method goes roughly like this. The 15 members of the Security Council hold secret straw polls on the candidates, over and over, until one candidate is acceptable to enough of them, and in particular acceptable to all five of the ones that matter most. In poll after poll, one name has come out on top: Rebeca Grynspan, the 70-year-old Costa Rican economist who runs UNCTAD, the UN’s trade and development body. As Urooba Jamal writes for Al Jazeera, a Grynspan win would make her the first woman and the first Jewish person to be secretary-general. She has led every poll so far. She has not won.
Here is how the scoring works. Each council member marks each candidate “encourage,” “discourage” or “no opinion.” To get the council’s recommendation, which then goes to the General Assembly for approval, a candidate needs at least nine encourages and no veto from any of the five permanent members: the US, Russia, China, France and the UK. In the eighth straw poll on November 5, Grynspan got 12 encourages and three discourages, her best result so far, up from 11 and four on October 30. Rafael Grossi of Argentina, who heads the International Atomic Energy Agency, came second with nine.
So she has three more votes than she needs. She also has three votes against her, and if any one of them belongs to a permanent member, the 12 are decorative.

The odd thing about the format is that most rounds don’t tell you which kind of no you are getting. Some polls are colour-coded: permanent members mark different-coloured ballots, so everyone can see whether a discourage is an opinion or a veto. The sixth poll was one of those, and it showed two permanent members and three elected members discouraging Grynspan. Grossi and Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett each also drew two red discourages in that round. The seventh and eighth polls didn’t split the votes out, and Security Council Report noted that the newer results therefore can’t tell you whether permanent-member opposition to her has softened. Run the numbers: she went from five discourages to three. Suppose, purely as a hypothetical, that the two who dropped away were both elected members. Then the remaining three could include both permanent members from before, and nothing would have changed except the headline. You can read the improvement as momentum or as noise, and the system is set up so nobody outside the room can say which.
Whose veto?
Which permanent member is blocking her is not publicly known, so people speculate. Richard Gowan of the International Crisis Group has suggested Russia might veto her because she criticised Moscow for pulling out of the Black Sea grain deal. She helped broker that deal in 2022 while being treated for breast cancer. According to UNCTAD, it shipped 32 million tonnes of grain and cut global food prices by 22% before Russia withdrew a year later. She met Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in April. Diplomats cited by Devex said that earlier this month the US and Russia backed the UAE’s Lana Nusseibeh, with France and the UK putting up “little resistance”. Six of the 15 council members voted against Nusseibeh in the latest poll, though nobody knows whether any of those were vetoes. The New York Times has reported that China has signalled it would like a Latin American candidate but has publicly endorsed nobody.

Then there is Washington. Analysts say winning over Donald Trump, who has tried to weaken the UN, may be the hardest part, partly because she is seen as a UN insider. Esther Brimmer of the Council on Foreign Relations said Grynspan has to show commitment to “reform, reorganisation, and consolidation,” adding that “an insider candidate has to work much harder” to prove she will drive change. Brimmer said US officials have stressed reform consistently, and how reform gets defined may decide the outcome.
Grynspan’s campaign lines read like they were written with that reader in mind. “The UN has to embrace reform, not be defensive about reform,” she told Al Jazeera. “The UN must become less risk-averse. Its biggest risk today is the risk of not trying.” In plain English: I know the place inside out, and I am also, believe me, very annoyed with it.
The trouble is that her CV makes the insider case for her. She was Costa Rica’s second vice-president from 1994 to 1998. Before that, as deputy finance minister, she played a key role in the 1980s debt crisis. In 2014 the 22 member countries of the Ibero-American Conference made her their secretary-general. She has held senior jobs at the UN Development Programme and on the UN commission for Haiti’s reconstruction, and in 2021 she became UNCTAD’s first female head. The experience that qualifies her for the job is the same experience she now has to argue isn’t a problem.

Her background has also drawn scrutiny from both sides of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Her sister lives in Israel, and her niece and nephew served in its military. Under her leadership, UNCTAD published reports blaming Israeli occupation policies for the collapse of the Palestinian economy. One of them put losses at $212.2bn between 2000 and 2024. She condemned Hamas’s October 2023 attack and called for a ceasefire in Gaza. According to Haaretz, Israeli officials have not commented on her candidacy. “What my identity gives me is empathy, not bias,” she said.
The clock
António Guterres’s second term ends on December 31. There are eight candidates in a secret ballot, and the newest, Turkey’s Feridun Sinirlioğlu, was only nominated on November 1. The council’s president for November, Latvian Ambassador Sanita Pavļuta-Deslandes, has warned that the window to agree on a candidate is closing. With less than seven weeks to go, the council has held eight closed-door polls and still has no consensus. As of early November, no date had been set for a ninth, and nobody knew whether it would be colour-coded, which is the one detail that would actually tell anyone something.
“Any mediator knows that 10 ideas may fail before the 11th succeeds,” Grynspan said. She has had eight polls, so by her own count she has two or three still to go. Whether there is time for them before New Year’s Eve is a separate question.
