On November 2, the French education ministry counted 42 high schools blocked out of the country’s 3,700 lycées, a shade over 1% of the total. The Union syndicale lycéenne, the main student union, counted 169. The next day the ministry’s count rose to 48; the union’s rose to 500, ten times the official figure. Both are nominally measuring the same thing: how many school gates were shut by students that morning. They disagree by an order of magnitude because they are measuring it differently, and nobody referees the dispute.

A blocus in French secondary schools is not run by a national organisation with a membership roll. Students at an individual lycée pile up trash bins, chain a gate, or simply stand in the entrance before first period; whether that counts as a closed school is a judgment call the ministry makes from headteacher reports and the union makes from its own networks. The movement that produces these numbers started on September 17 at a school in Créteil, southeast of Paris, and by the end of that month had reportedly spread to roughly 400 establishments, a tally that more than doubled within two weeks by the government’s own later count. There is no steering committee to ask for a single number, which is why none exists.

Two tallies, two months

The same split shows up in protest turnout. On October 17, the interior ministry counted about 550,000 people nationwide; organisers claimed roughly 800,000. On November 5, a one-day general strike that unions dubbed “Black Thursday” and that drew in the CGT, the CFDT, yellow-vest activists and students alongside the lycéens, the interior ministry counted 575,000; the CGT counted 1.57 million, according to live coverage by Ouest-France. The gap between the two counting methods has stayed roughly the same multiple, 1.5 to 2.7 times, across seven weeks of protest, which is its own kind of consistency.

Mobilisations en France : des lycéens maintiennent les blocus avant le cortège • FRANCE 24
France 24 filmed lycée students maintaining blockades on the morning of November 5 ahead of that day’s nationwide march. Video: FRANCE 24 · YouTube

The damage, and a stabbing

On November 5 alone, the Île-de-France region reported more than 200 lycées disrupted, about 50 of them the scene of actual violence, and roughly 30 gates or entrance locks damaged, at a cost the regional authority put above €1 million, according to live reporting by Europe1, which separately counted at least 81 schools blockaded that day and a school set alight in Toulouse. That one-day figure sits on top of an earlier estimate: regional president Valérie Pécresse had already put cumulative damage to Île-de-France school buildings at €7 million as of October 2. Near Toulouse, the Lycée Françoise in Tournefeuille was evacuated after fireworks set part of the building on fire; a préfet reported serious damage at the Rostand and Fresnel lycées. On the margins of a blockade in Île-de-France that same Thursday morning, police found a 15-year-old with a stab wound to the chest.

Why students are still outside the gates

The grievances that opened the movement in September have not gone away by mid-November. At the Bartholdi trade school in Saint-Denis, 17-year-old Nohlan told Al Jazeera in reporting published November 17: “we see rats in the courtyard and in the restrooms,” describing slow-running water and dirty classrooms. “There’s still no change,” he said. At the nearby Paul Eluard high school, students and teachers gathering outside the locked gates that same week mixed costumes with the anger.

“Costumes are the fun part. They show that it’s not all about violence. There’s also good cheer and fun in all of this,” said Kamelia, 17, one of the students outside Paul Eluard.

Teachers at Paul Eluard separately demanded the resignation of headteacher Xavier Artaud, who they said let a motorised antiterrorism-brigade officer into the school to arrest a student; Artaud stepped down, which his academic director attributed to “unacceptable public accusations” made against him, as a safety precaution, Al Jazeera reported. Three days earlier, a similar standoff played out at the Decours lycée in Paris, where police physically prevented students from setting up a blockade on November 10.

Lycéens : la police empêche le blocus du lycée Decours à Paris ce 10 novembre
Footage shows police blocking students attempting to set up a blockade at the Lycée Decours in Paris on November 10. Video: CLPRESS / Agence de presse · YouTube

What the budget actually does

Behind the gate-rattling is a specific finance bill. Falling enrolment, 180,000 fewer pupils expected for the 2027 school year after a drop of 160,000 this year, would on its own have justified cutting roughly 9,600 teaching posts, by the education ministry’s own arithmetic, cited by La Gazette des Communes. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu’s 2027 budget instead cut 1,588 posts: 1,250 in public schools (414 in primary, 836 in middle and high schools) and 338 in subsidised private schools, alongside a headline increase of €1.2 billion, to roughly €64 billion in total for the ministry.

Facing the blockades, the government moved once already. On October 26, education minister Edouard Geffray and higher-education minister Philippe Baptiste announced they would cancel the 836 secondary-school cuts by amendment, leaving the 414 primary-school and 338 private-school cuts in place, according to reporting by NosParlementaires. Three days later a finance-committee amendment, filed by LFI deputy Rodrigo Arenas, attached €83 million to what it called an “urgent plan” to recruit the 1,588 positions originally cut; that figure is a procedural placeholder rather than the real cost, since individual deputies cannot expand a ministry’s total envelope on their own. None of it is final: under the French constitution’s Article 42, floor debate on a finance bill restarts from the government’s original text, so committee amendments have to be re-filed and re-voted in the full Assembly, where the education budget was due to reach the floor on November 12.

Red scissors hover above four shortened yellow pencils and one sharpened yellow pencil wrapped in tape against a blue background.

Measured against the students’ own demands, the arithmetic still favours the government by a wide margin. The USL and other unions have called for a €10 billion increase to the education budget, a €1.5 billion infrastructure programme and 250,000 additional university places. The €1.2 billion increase Lecornu has put on the table is an eighth of what’s being asked for.

The political framing around the numbers has its own dispute. Val-de-Marne lawmaker Louis Boyard, who as a student took part in a 2018 lycée blockade over asbestos that led to his own school being rebuilt, has argued Macron’s government favours private education funding over public.

“One in three French people are skipping meals,” Boyard told Al Jazeera, framing the schools dispute inside a wider cost-of-living argument.

Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s France Unbowed, polling around 20% for the presidency, has been accused by opponents of steering the movement for its own ends; Boyard denies it. Macron himself, after opening the Élysée to student representatives in October, has spoken of addressing youth “anxieties” over climate, technology and geopolitics in the “most concrete way possible,” without attaching a further number to that promise.

Geffray told France Inter radio after students returned from their autumn break that the remaining blockades amounted to “a handful of units, a few individual schools,” a characterisation the ministry’s own November 2 and 3 counts, 42 and 48 schools out of 3,700, roughly support, even as the union count ten times higher and the continuing standoffs at Bartholdi, Paul Eluard and Decours suggest the movement has not ended so much as shrunk to its most committed pockets. The Assembly’s vote on the education budget, and whether the 414 primary-school cuts the government has so far declined to reverse survive it, is the next number to watch.