Running a New England boarding school is, among other things, a hotel business with a very particular customer problem. The number of dorm beds and classroom seats is fixed and the fixed costs are high. The price, tuition that often tops $80,000 a year, has outrun inflation for so long that only the richest American families can pay it, and those families mostly have good private and public schools close to home. Meanwhile the supply of American teenagers is shrinking, the so-called “demographic cliff.” So who pays full price for a bed in rural Connecticut?
Increasingly, families from abroad. Mostly from China.
That is the backdrop to the mess at Suffield Academy, which Mike Damiano unpacks in the Boston Globe. Charles Cahn III, Suffield’s longtime head of school, went on leave in October and then resigned amid an IRS investigation into his finances, the details of which have not been made public (I covered his exit here). Around the same time a Suffield board member, Lillian Chen, stepped down. Chen and her husband ran a Chinese company, XueMei Education, that promised “high net worth” Chinese families it could “ensure admission” to selective American boarding schools like Suffield. XueMei repeatedly hosted events with Cahn in China. To be clear, there is no public evidence of wrongdoing by Chen or Cahn, and hiring someone to help your kid apply to boarding school is a perfectly normal thing to do.
Still, “ensure admission” is worth translating. Admission is supposed to be something the school decides, on the merits, and a consultant can make an application better but cannot really promise the outcome. A firm that promises the outcome is implicitly telling customers that it has some edge with the school. Maybe that edge is just good essay coaching and lots of confidence. But when one of the people running the firm also sits on the school’s board, you can see why someone might wonder.

The economics
Here is the money. In China, admissions consultants typically charge $100,000 or more to get a student through the boarding school process, according to consultants who have worked there, and $300,000 contracts are not unheard of. In New England a consulting package typically costs under $10,000, and the high end tops out around $40,000. So the Chinese floor is roughly ten times the typical American package and well above the American ceiling. Some consultants, known as “agents,” also collect from the other side: a commission from the school worth as much as 10 percent of a student’s tuition. On $80,000 a year, that is up to $8,000, for a single student, from the school that admitted them.
Neil Chyten, an admissions consultant in Newton, explained the demand side: “The thing about China is that you’ve got a relatively small percentage of the population that has extraordinary wealth. And they don’t mind spending on education.” Chyten used to subcontract for Chinese consulting firms and stopped, partly because he worried they were ripping off their clients, charging families far more than they paid him to do the actual work. Which tells you where the margin was.
The schools at the very top don’t need any of this. Exeter and Andover have endowments above $1 billion, fill their classes without effort and can admit students without regard to what their parents pay. Second-tier schools like Suffield have much smaller endowments and lean harder on full-tuition students. “The vast majority of private schools are just dying to get clients,” Chyten said. Note the word “clients.”

And the donors
Full-pay students are half of it. Schools also raise money abroad, and some New England boarding schools have set up charitable foundations in Hong Kong to make giving from China easier. Eaglebrook School, a middle-school boarding school in Deerfield, has received at least $5.6 million from its Hong Kong foundation over the past decade, according to public tax filings, or an average of at least $560,000 a year. Its head, Andrew C. Chase, regularly travels to China to raise money and recruit. Karen Corday, an Eaglebrook spokesperson, said that “learning about and celebrating life experiences of others broadens and deepens our students’ understanding of other cultures.” She also said Cahn served on Eaglebrook’s board until Nov. 3, when he was “relieved of all duties.”
For Suffield, the XueMei relationship seems to have done both jobs at once. It brought in students, and it helped the school get a foothold with potential donors. The same firm recruits families and introduces the school to people with money, and some of the families are presumably the people with money. That is efficient. It is also exactly the kind of overlap a conflict-of-interest policy exists to deal with.
Peter Wood, president of the National Association of Scholars and a China critic, thinks American schools are “naive” about all this. “If you’ve acquired large amounts of material resources in China, you have done so with the permission, encouragement, and aid of the government in Beijing,” he said. He also said the two countries have different expectations about paying for access: “Bribery is how you do business in China.” A consultant named McMillan, who frequently works abroad, takes a milder view, saying there absolutely are “ethical ways to vet and recruit Chinese students,” though it takes special expertise. His own firm doesn’t try: “We choose to outsource and refer to others that really nuanced and complex Chinese market.”

Suffield is not alone
XueMei hosted the top admissions official of the Peddie School, in New Jersey, at a Shanghai event last year, and in 2024 it advertised events with admissions officers from nine other schools. Tabor Academy, in Marion, has a board member, Ngai Suet, who is a principal at a Chinese admissions consulting firm called Shang NancyFriends. Another consultant from the same firm sits on the board of the Hill School, a highly selective boarding school near Philadelphia. Shang NancyFriends says it has placed students at both schools. It did not respond to requests for comment.
The Independent Educational Consultants Association, a trade group, says being a board member and an admissions consultant at once can create a conflict of interest. Its Principles of Good Practice for its members list serving on a school’s board as a “multiple relationship” to avoid, and say that where one exists the consultant must disclose it in writing, including a consent form for clients to sign.
Tabor’s spokesperson, Michelle Turner, said Ngai had “disclosed her work with Shang NancyFriends” and “has complied, and continues to comply, with all policies and procedures regarding her service on the Board.” The statement doesn’t say who she disclosed it to. The school, of course, already knows who sits on its board. The trade group’s version of disclosure points the other way, at the families paying the consultant, who might like to know which boards their consultant sits on before they pay six figures for a promise.

