In every court there are people whose fortunes rise and fall on what the sovereign says. Usually they are courtiers. Since February 2025 they could also be anyone with an account on Kalshi, the American prediction market, which let its customers bet on which words would come out of President Donald Trump’s mouth, and when.

That trade is now suspended. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal agency that regulates Kalshi, has ordered the company to stop offering the contracts while it decides whether they break the federal ban on markets that are “readily susceptible to manipulation.” On Tuesday, November 17, the Wall Street Journal reported, citing people familiar with the matter, that Kalshi was pulling the markets, according to Gizmodo. The order itself, as Jon Brodkin reported for Ars Technica, uses language a regulator rarely aims at a company it has otherwise been defending in court.

“Given the available supporting evidence, including that Kalshi has not attempted to establish that the Contracts are non-manipulable with respect to the Staff Advisory’s guidance, the Commission presumptively believes the certification is false.”

A market in nicknames

The goods for sale were small. In one market, as Gizmodo described it, customers could bet on whether the president would say “Marjorie Traitor Greene” or “Sleepy Joe” before the end of April. The order, issued on November 13 according to Finance Magnates, covers the TRUMPSAY contract series and a market titled “What nicknames will Trump say before 2027?”

A gold padlock with a blank speech bubble floats above a dark podium and microphone against a red background.

Kalshi self-certified the series in February 2025. Under that system the exchange itself vouches that its products comply with federal law, and the regulator steps in afterwards, if at all. For a year and a half nobody stepped in.

Then, on September 22, the CFTC’s Division of Market Oversight issued a staff advisory on mention markets, The Block reported. The reasoning was plain. When a contract settles on whether one named person says one word, that person, or anyone near enough to influence them, can simply decide the result. According to Decrypt’s account, staff said such contracts should be presumed manipulable, and gave the example of a podcast host who can say a catchphrase whenever they like. Exchanges could still list mention markets, but only after making a “heightened showing” that they could not easily be rigged. The advisory, signed by acting director Duncan Hennes, does not bind the Commission. Jaret Seiberg of TD Securities said it “effectively” closes the “vast majority” of such markets.

Kalshi’s answer, as the Commission tells it, was to list the nicknames contract roughly a week later “without amending the [TRUMPSAY] Contract Series’ self-certification (or submitting a new self-certification) to make the ‘heightened showing’ of non-manipulability required by the Staff Advisory.”

The man at the teleprompter

The danger was no longer theoretical. Gabriel Perez, who had operated the president’s teleprompter, allegedly made more than $100,000 earlier this year by using his advance view of Trump’s speeches to bet correctly on Kalshi. In August he settled with the CFTC and agreed to pay $172,000 in penalties and forfeited profits.

Gold coins fall from a tilted solar panel into an outstretched hand against a blue background.

It is hard to find a better parable of how information moves through a palace. The text reaches the screen before it reaches the crowd, and the man between the two can turn that gap into money. Kalshi and its rival Polymarket both prohibit insider trading. Both also sell the idea that people trading on what they know make the markets more accurate. The teleprompter case is where those two promises run into each other.

What the order does not say

The Commission was careful. It has not found that a market in presidential speech can never meet the law’s standard. It found only that Kalshi has not shown this one does. The order “resolves only that, based on the current record, Kalshi has not demonstrated that the Contracts as certified comply with the Act and that the Contracts should not trade while the Commission completes its review.” A proceeding will now decide whether the certification was false. Kalshi has until December 11 to explain in writing why it was not. Finance Magnates reported that no penalty has been imposed.

Kalshi’s chief executive, Tarek Mansour, argued the case for the product at an Axios event on Tuesday, according to Bloomberg. “What the president does say moves markets,” he said. “So predicting what he’s about to say is actually pretty meaningful.”

Read as reflection rather than fact, that may be the most honest description of power in the whole affair: one man’s words are worth betting on because they shift prices everywhere else. Kalshi did not answer either outlet’s request for comment.

A hand holds strings attached to a rising and falling line graph against a red background.

A regulator on two fronts

The halt is narrower than it looks. Kalshi confirmed it withdrew the Trump markets on November 17, DeFi Rate reported. Contracts that had already resolved stay settled. The company still lists mention markets about other politicians and corporate executives, although Reuters reported that it had earlier stopped many others at the CFTC’s request, including every sports-related one. Bloomberg noted that Polymarket’s international site, which the CFTC does not regulate, still had live markets on Trump’s speeches. Polymarket also runs a separate US-regulated version.

Then there is the odd position of the regulator itself. Even as it squeezes the mention markets, the CFTC is defending Kalshi and Polymarket against states that want to treat prediction markets as illegal gambling. That fight has been going badly for the platforms: a federal appeals court ruled that states can enforce their gambling laws against Kalshi, and Kalshi and Coinbase lost their bid to stop New York and Connecticut. Only days before this order, the agency had warned Kalshi it might face charges over new contract filings.

Congress is watching too. Earlier this year lawmakers introduced a bill to ban trading on outcomes that are known in advance or can be controlled by individuals. It followed cases of large profits on suspiciously well-timed bets tied to wars abroad. New markets on drug trials and flight cancellations have raised the same fear: that someone with the means to tamper with a clinical trial or ground a flight might also have a position riding on the result.

Until December 11, at least, there is no legal market in the president’s next word. He will keep talking regardless.