---
title: "Three Paris officers await verdict in Zecler beating, and the report they signed"
description: "Prosecutors want four to six years in prison for the beating of a Black music producer, plus the police report footage showed was false"
author: "Nate Ledger"
published: 2026-11-19T18:51:50Z
modified: 2026-11-20T13:16:46Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/three-paris-officers-await-verdict-in-zecler-beating-and-the-b4dc83
language: en
tags: ["police", "racism", "justice", "law", "france", "europe"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# Three Paris officers await verdict in Zecler beating, and the report they signed

*Prosecutors want four to six years in prison for the beating of a Black music producer, plus the police report footage showed was false*

By Nate Ledger · November 19, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/three-paris-officers-await-verdict-in-zecler-beating-and-the-b4dc83

## In brief

- A Paris court was due to rule on 20 November in the case of three officers who beat music producer Michel Zecler in 2020
- The officers also face forgery charges over a signed report claiming Zecler hit them, which surveillance footage contradicted
- Prosecutors asked for prison terms of six, five and four years and permanent bans from the police
- The officers admitted to illegitimate blows and apologised but deny Zecler’s account that they used racist language
- The Senate is weighing a bill, passed by the Assembly in July, that would presume police acted in self-defence when firing

On 21 November 2020, three Paris police officers followed Michel Zecler, a Black music producer, into his studio and beat him. Surveillance footage shows them pushing him inside and hitting him until other musicians stepped in. Aurelien Lapersonne, Pierre Plantier and Philippe Tondeux are accused of striking him 29 times in four minutes, and six more times in the face after he was already handcuffed. They allegedly made several racist remarks during the attack. Six years almost to the day later, the Paris criminal court was due to give its verdict on Friday, as [Sophie Stuber reported for *Al Jazeera*](https://aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/19/france-awaits-verdict-six-years-after-police-beat-black-music-producer).

The beating is the part everyone remembers. At the time Kylian Mbappe shared an image of Zecler with blood running down his face, captioned: “Unbearable video. Unacceptable violence”. But the second charge is the one that explains how the system is supposed to work, and why it nearly didn’t. The three officers are also accused of forging a public document.

## The report

When police arrest someone, they write an official account of what happened, and that account becomes the starting point for everything after it. Prosecutors read it, judges read it, and when it is the only account on file it carries a lot of weight. All three officers signed a report saying Zecler had hit them. Lapersonne, who began the identity check and filed the report, wrote that Zecler “struck out with his arms and legs.” The report also left out the fact that the officers had hit him at all. (The stop began over Zecler not wearing a mask, [NPR reported in 2020](https://www.npr.org/2020/11/30/940028204/french-police-could-face-assault-charges-in-beating-that-sparked-protests).)

In court, the presiding judge asked Lapersonne whether he had “made that up.” He answered: “Absolutely.” On the missing blows, he said: “I deliberately omitted them. I think out of fear. It was stupid of me.” According to [franceinfo’s account of the testimony](https://www.franceinfo.fr/faits-divers/producteur-passe-a-tabac-par-des-policiers/une-volonte-de-se-proteger-au-proces-du-tabassage-de-michel-zecler-un-policier-reconnait-des-mensonges-les-autres-des-erreurs-dans-le-proces-verbal-d-interpellation_8288621.html), one officer admitted to “lies” in the arrest report while the other two spoke of “errors.”

![Fountain pens surround a torn sheet of paper illuminated by a red beam from a surveillance camera.](https://rews.cc/img/c7cc72c339ea8bdced592967c285668e3a5fe3c2.webp)

Consider what that report would have done if the studio camera had not existed. It would have been the official record. It described a man attacking three officers, so the obvious next step would have been to prosecute him. The prosecutor in the case said as much at the close of the trial, [according to franceinfo](https://www.franceinfo.fr/faits-divers/producteur-passe-a-tabac-par-des-policiers/des-peines-de-quatre-ans-a-six-ans-de-prison-ferme-requises-contre-les-trois-policiers-accuses-d-avoir-roue-de-coups-michel-zecler_8288789.html): “Today, fortunately, we avoided a miscarriage of justice concerning Mr Zecler.” She also said: “If we accept that police officers lie, it is the end of the functioning of our democracy.”

Rim-Sarah Alouane, a legal scholar and associate researcher in public law at the University of Toulouse Capitole, made the same point more bluntly: “If there was no footage, we would not be here today. The police would have gotten away with it.” In her view the falsified paperwork is what makes the case: “When these reports are falsified, we’re questioning the integrity of the entire system.”

## What the prosecution wants

The prosecution asked for prison terms with no suspension: six years for Lapersonne, five for Tondeux, who led the group and was the most experienced officer there, and four for Plantier. It also asked for all three to be permanently barred from the police. Both the charges carry a maximum of 15 years. The prosecutor asked for a deferred committal order, which means that if the court agrees, the officers would go to prison a few weeks after the verdict, not on the day. She also asked the court to find that the violence was racially aggravated, an element the investigating judges had dropped for lack of evidence. Zecler maintains he was called a racial slur. The officers deny any racism.

![A large judge’s gavel hovers above three hanging jackets, with a red streak beneath it in a black-and-white halftone illustration.](https://rews.cc/img/b5cee4cc35c448181548faf7b358b0d0ade18f31.webp)

> There is no room for a symbolic sentence. We are talking about crimes, violence and racial slurs. About a complete lack of control over what was done and an absolute determination to get away with it in the end.

That was the prosecutor’s office. During the trial, which opened on 9 November, all three officers admitted that some of their blows were “illegitimate,” and before the judges withdrew they apologised to Zecler again. [Ouest-France](https://www.ouest-france.fr/societe/justice/mes-excuses-a-michel-zecler-et-pour-limage-donnee-de-la-police-les-trois-agents-dans-lattente-de-la-decision-9148bd34-e4bb-11f1-bd4e-6f30b8f49e21) quoted one apology in its headline: “My apologies to Michel Zecler and for the image given of the police.” The prosecutor’s answer, before the final statements, was: “Despite the apologies, all this is not enough.”

## The presumption

The case lands in the middle of a wider argument over who has to prove what. The European Court of Human Rights condemned France last year for the racial profiling of Karim Touil, a young French national of North African origin whom police stopped three times in 10 days in late 2011. In October 2023 a top French court recognised racial profiling in identity checks but, as Human Rights Watch noted, did not order the authorities to take the “necessary measures to end this longstanding, abusive practice.” In 2021 the state was found liable for “gross negligence” over identity checks on three high school students at Gare du Nord.

![A red magnifying glass focuses on a person with a backpack on a Paris street, with the Eiffel Tower in the background.](https://rews.cc/img/2b5660f7019af93d6c7fa84fbe0bd436fa8ad9e9.webp)

The French Senate is now considering a bill, which the National Assembly passed in July, that would presume police officers and gendarmes acted in self-defence when they use their firearms on duty. In practice that moves the burden of proof onto the person complaining. Critics call it a “licence to kill.” As [rews has written before](https://rews.cc/a/a-marseille-father-a-lost-case-file-and-the-french-bill-that-907181), it reverses the default: the officer’s account is taken as true unless a complainant can show otherwise.

No shots were fired in Zecler’s studio, and the bill as described covers firearms. Alouane’s argument is that the logic carries over: “If this proposal were in place, we would not have this case. It would have been dismissed today.” She called the bill “liberticide” and said it “puts a presumption of innocence in favour of people because of their profession as cops.” The Zecler case shows how much rides on that default. Here the officers’ account was written down, signed by all three and wrong, and it took a private camera to overturn it.

French police tactics are also under scrutiny after recent student protests, in which a 15-year-old lost a hand to a stun grenade and a tear gas canister fired at close range shattered a 14-year-old’s jaw and several teeth.

The report carried three officers’ signatures. Nobody signed the footage, and the footage is what held up.
