---
title: "The Supreme Court says nothing, and UC researchers keep their DEI grants"
description: "The justices turned away Trump v. Thakur with no comment and no noted dissent, leaving a Ninth Circuit First Amendment ruling standing"
author: "Jan Sokol"
published: 2026-11-16T19:54:21Z
modified: 2026-11-17T04:59:06Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/the-supreme-court-says-nothing-and-uc-researchers-keep-their-b58a8f
language: en
tags: ["law", "supreme-court", "dei", "education", "politics", "us"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# The Supreme Court says nothing, and UC researchers keep their DEI grants

*The justices turned away Trump v. Thakur with no comment and no noted dissent, leaving a Ninth Circuit First Amendment ruling standing*

By Jan Sokol · November 16, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/the-supreme-court-says-nothing-and-uc-researchers-keep-their-b58a8f

## In brief

- On Nov. 16, 2026 the Supreme Court denied review in Trump v. Thakur without comment or noted dissent
- The case concerns UC researchers’ grants cancelled under Trump’s anti-DEI executive orders, reported at $59 million
- In May 2026 the Ninth Circuit upheld the injunction for the DEI class, finding likely viewpoint discrimination
- Solicitor General Sauer argued the ruling would ‘hamstring every future administration’
- The injunction holds while the case continues; the denial keeps such disputes in federal district courts

Sometimes the highest court in the land speaks loudest by saying nothing. On Monday, November 16, the Supreme Court of the United States took a petition from the Trump administration, the case called *Trump v. Thakur*, docket No. 26-210, and turned it away. It offered no opinion and no explanation, and no justice put a dissent on the record. The petition was denied, as [SCOTUSblog recorded](https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/11/supreme-court-turns-down-dei-related-disputes-and-second-amendment-challenge-to-gun-bans-in-sens/), “without comment or noted dissent.”

Behind that silence sit professors of the University of California. Federal agencies cancelled their research grants after the president’s executive orders against diversity, equity and inclusion, and the money is worth tens of millions of dollars. Because the justices declined to step in, it goes on flowing to them.

## A form letter and an executive order

The story starts the way much bureaucratic power starts in this era, with a document. Some researchers got a termination notice that, in the court’s description, “does not provide a grant-specific explanation for the termination.” Others saw their funding cut under the DEI orders themselves. Six UC professors brought a class action. According to [the *Daily Californian*](https://dailycal.org/news/uc/supreme-court-denies-trump-administration-bid-to-terminate-dei-related-uc-research-grants/article_796c2c41-2e0c-4cb2-a243-bdf8cf636aa7.html), it was led by Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the UC Berkeley School of Law, and Claudia Polsky, who directs its Environmental Law Clinic.

In June 2025 a federal district court in California ordered the grants restored for both groups, the form-letter class and the DEI class. The researchers’ argument was that the cancellations amounted to viewpoint discrimination and so violated the First Amendment.

![Navy scissors cut across a cream classical column beside a laboratory flask containing yellow liquid, with yellow circles falling into it against a teal background.](https://rews.cc/img/cc93aa0c8f183c91407aaf7a3c5dba2408558288.webp)

Then came the government’s partial victory. In August 2025 the Supreme Court, splitting 5-4, [allowed the National Institutes of Health](https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/08/supreme-court-allows-trump-administration-to-terminate-783-million-in-nih-grants-linked-to-dei-initiatives/) to terminate $783 million in grants linked to DEI initiatives. When the Ninth Circuit ruled on the UC case in May 2026, it leaned on that order and reversed the district court on the form-letter class, finding the lower court probably had no authority over that claim. The researchers who had been dismissed with a template lost.

Those who had been cut for their ideas won.

## The line between a program and a speaker

The appeals panel drew a distinction that sounds small and is not. A government, it held, may scrap a whole grant program it no longer thinks worthwhile. What it may not do is reach inside an existing program and pull individual grants whose views it dislikes. That, the panel wrote, as [John Timmer reported for *Ars Technica*](https://arstechnica.com/science/2026/11/supreme-court-keeps-injunction-against-dei-grant-defunding-in-place/), is an attempt at the “suppression of dangerous ideas.” To support this it cited the Supreme Court’s own precedents on discrimination against religious viewpoints.

DEI fits that framework, the court reasoned, because such work “convey\[s\] the viewpoint that the exclusion of historically disadvantaged groups is undesirable.” Its conclusion followed:

> the government has not merely exercised its power to choose the programs it funds but has instead terminated individual grants in existing programs based on the perceived viewpoints of individual speakers.

![A hand picks a red speech bubble flower from a yellow planter containing three cream speech bubble flowers with connected roots against a teal background.](https://rews.cc/img/25ecf54981c43ec92fef7892f1256d30763a6e8d.webp)

Elsewhere the panel wrote that once a subsidy program exists, the government “may not discriminate between speakers within that program to suppress viewpoints with which it disagrees.” The terminations at issue, [The Hill reported](https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/6222654-scotus-declines-trump-dei-appeal/) among others, came to $59 million in grants.

## What the Solicitor General asked for

Solicitor General D. John Sauer did not argue modestly. The Ninth Circuit’s ruling, he told the justices, “conflicts with” Supreme Court precedent and sets “a dangerous precedent that will hamstring every future administration.” The First Amendment, in his words, “does not require taxpayers to continue funding projects that the government concludes no longer serve the public interest.” The administration has made a similar argument before, in [a Boston courtroom](https://rews.cc/a/in-a-boston-courtroom-the-government-argues-there-is-no-firs-127472), where it maintained that the First Amendment confers no right to money.

The researchers answered that the circuits do not disagree, and that the government cannot point to any case allowing it to terminate competitively awarded grants “based on the perceived viewpoint of the research.”

The court sided with neither in words. In effect it sided with the researchers.

## Reading a silence

A refused petition decides nothing on the merits. The injunction only bars the cuts while the lawsuit continues, and the case goes back to the lower courts, where the justices may yet get another chance to intervene. Still, the silence was striking, because the Court could easily have found something to object to, from the venue to the finding of viewpoint discrimination. Timmer suggests other courts may take the lack of intervention as a sign that the government’s anti-DEI campaign stands on shaky legal ground.

![A dark gavel with yellow bands rests on a cream cushion beside a microscope against a bright blue background.](https://rews.cc/img/790b8b0dd77830d9fd43d9d6aca4e9bb5d276faf.webp)

Venue is no trifle here. The administration has long tried to push grant disputes into the Court of Federal Claims, a specialised tribunal, and away from the district courts. Steve Vladeck, the legal analyst, [told CNN](https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/politics/supreme-court-trump-grants) that the denial matters “in at least tacitly endorsing the lower courts’ conclusion that these kinds of disputes properly belong in federal district courts, rather than the specialized federal claims court.”

On the same order list the justices turned away another DEI-adjacent case, *Khatibi v. Yip*, No. 25-1240. A California ophthalmologist had challenged the state Medical Board’s requirement that continuing medical education address “the understanding of implicit bias.” There the silence was not unanimous. Justice Gorsuch would have taken the case. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, wrote that the Ninth Circuit “fundamentally misunderstands” precedent and that “First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech.” On the UC grants none of the three wrote a word.

It is, one might reflect, an old lesson about power. The ruler cannot stop the money already spent on a program. He can stop the money paid to a single scholar, and that is where his reach feels most personal. Federal judges have now marked that as the point where the First Amendment applies. This autumn they have done it [more than once](https://rews.cc/a/two-courts-in-eight-hours-tell-trump-the-first-amendment-sti-9778af). In the laboratories and seminar rooms of the University of California, the work that was meant to stop is going on, at least while the case lasts.
