For thirty years a rule in California said something very simple. If you live in AT&T’s territory and you ask for a telephone, AT&T must give you one. The rule had a bureaucrat’s name, Carrier of Last Resort, and like many bureaucrats’ names it hid a promise. On Friday, November 20, 2026, the Federal Communications Commission in Washington told California it may no longer enforce that promise against AT&T.
The order, as Jon Brodkin reported for Ars Technica, grants AT&T’s request to preempt the state’s rules. It finishes a job the commission started earlier, when it approved AT&T’s petition to discontinue service. The company wants to stop offering basic phone service to new customers and, on June 1, 2027, to end it for 184,000 residential customers and 15,000 business customers. Broadband Breakfast reported that the earlier approval covered more than 184,000 locations served by 360 wire centers, and that AT&T sought preemption under Section 253 of the Communications Act, arguing that the state was blocking a network transition Washington had already authorized.
Twenty states, and one
AT&T’s wireline territory covers 21 states. In 20 of them it has already won relief from its last-resort obligations. California was the exception. In 2024 the California Public Utilities Commission turned down AT&T’s application to shed the status, after more than 5,000 public comments and eight public forums, according to an earlier Broadband Breakfast report.
So the company went to court. It sued in May, arguing that federal policy encouraging carriers to retire old copper networks overrides the state’s rules. In July U.S. District Judge Linda Lopez of the Southern District of California denied its request for a preliminary injunction, which left the rules in force while the case goes on. That same month AT&T asked the FCC for what the judge had refused it. On October 30, Light Reading reported, the commission said Chairman Brendan Carr had circulated a draft order. Three weeks later it was adopted.
Here is a reflection, not a finding. A powerful petitioner who loses in one forum does not stop asking. It finds another forum, one that answers to a friendlier administration.
A bygone era
Carr’s statement treated the state’s rules as something left over from the past.
California’s Carrier of Last Resort framework may have made sense when it was established 30 years ago. But those rules were designed for a bygone era and no longer make sense in today’s competitive, advanced marketplace.
“The FCC has granted AT&T’s applications to replace legacy voice service with a modern, IP-based alternative in certain areas of the state,” he said. “California’s state requirements are blocking AT&T from proceeding with a federally authorized transition.”
The word “modern” is doing a lot of work there. If AT&T switches off its copper, many of the homes and businesses on those lines will not be offered fiber, and the order does not require AT&T to build any. What they will get instead is a wireless home phone that connects to the cellular network. AT&T says that will be good enough. The commission agreed.
What the wire carried
California has never banned wireless replacements. Its position is that a replacement is fine if it meets the state’s standards for basic phone service, and that AT&T has to show that its wireless product does. Those standards are specific. There must be a flat-rate option for unlimited voice calls. Eligible low-income customers must get discounted Lifeline rates. People who are deaf or hard of hearing must have telephone relay service. These are the people the old rule was written for: the ones who cannot easily pay more and the ones who need a line that works for them. They are rarely the people who write to regulators.
Some people did write. Before the vote, members of Congress, Senator Adam Schiff among them, urged the commission to reject AT&T’s request. Their letter warned that “If the FCC adopts this order, it will eliminate California’s ability to require proof that wireless or fiber replacements actually work before copper wires are discontinued,” the Crescenta Valley Weekly reported. The Rural County Representatives of California, the Communications Workers of America and The Utility Reform Network argued that the Communications Act limits how far the FCC can override state authority.
The only Democrat on the commission, Anna Gomez, voted no. According to Broadband Breakfast and Light Reading, she said the state commission is already reviewing how to modernize its last-resort rules and that Washington should have let that process run its course.
June 1, 2027
Friday’s order is probably not the end of it. California could sue the commission. The state is already fighting AT&T in Judge Lopez’s court: in October the state attorney general and the utilities commission moved to dismiss the company’s lawsuit, and AT&T asked the court to refuse, Communications Daily reported. It argued that California’s rules, though written to be technology-neutral, in practice force it to keep its expensive copper running. This month Sacramento kept its net neutrality law while accepting federal broadband money. It has shown that it can say no to this administration and still keep the money.
The date in AT&T’s plan has not changed. Unless a court stays the order, it is June 1, 2027, and 199,000 customers will lose the service that state law once guaranteed them.
