---
title: "The FBI Played Both the Ransomware Victim and the Ransomware Gang to Test a Recovery Firm"
description: "Prosecutors say a Florida data-recovery firm’s “advanced cryptographic tools” were mostly bitcoin payments to the hackers, plus a markup"
author: "Nate Ledger"
published: 2026-11-19T18:11:50Z
modified: 2026-11-20T03:13:39Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/the-fbi-played-both-the-ransomware-victim-and-the-ransomware-783c27
language: en
tags: ["ransomware", "fbi", "cybersecurity", "fraud", "crime", "tech"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# The FBI Played Both the Ransomware Victim and the Ransomware Gang to Test a Recovery Firm

*Prosecutors say a Florida data-recovery firm’s “advanced cryptographic tools” were mostly bitcoin payments to the hackers, plus a markup*

By Nate Ledger · November 19, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/the-fbi-played-both-the-ransomware-victim-and-the-ransomware-783c27

## In brief

- Juan Ricardo Palacio Escobar was indicted in federal court in Rhode Island on three counts of wire fraud
- Prosecutors say his Florida firm claimed to decrypt ransomware victims’ files but secretly paid the gangs and marked up the cost
- In a June sting the FBI posed as both victim and hacker; the firm charged $13,260 and paid $6,003 for the key
- A Kansas business was allegedly charged $720,000 after Palacio paid hackers about $445,000
- In April, former ransomware negotiator Angelo Martino pleaded guilty to conspiring with the BlackCat gang

Here is a business model. A company gets hit by ransomware: its files are encrypted and a note on the screen tells it to pay up for the key. The company doesn’t want to pay. Maybe it’s a matter of principle, maybe the board said no, maybe it just finds the idea of wiring money to criminals distasteful. So it hires you, because you advertise “advanced cryptographic tools” that can “restore 100%” of its data without anyone paying a ransom. You take the job. Then you quietly email the criminals, pay the ransom, get the key, decrypt the files and send the client a bill for more than you paid.

In fairness, you did restore 100% of the data.

That, roughly, is what federal prosecutors say Juan Ricardo Palacio Escobar was doing. [As Mikael Thalen reported for 404 Media](https://404media.co/ransomware-fraud-attack-fbi-indictment/), working with the court-records outlet Court Watch, an indictment filed Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island charges Palacio with three counts of wire fraud. The indictment refers to his business, which he ran with an unnamed associate and which started in 2020, as “Company A.” According to prosecutors, it marketed itself as a data-recovery service for ransomware victims and had no special decryption capabilities at all. Palacio is charged, not convicted.

The indictment’s language is a nice specimen of the form:

> It was part of the scheme and artifice to defraud that PALACIO used Company A to intentionally misrepresent to companies in the United States who were victims of ransomware attacks that Company A could help them decrypt and recover their files without paying a ransom.

![A businessman offers an unlocked padlock to another man while a hooded figure steals coins from his pocket.](https://rews.cc/img/23d1137a1eb90bf32e96af965d14133a8166c7bb.webp)

Put plainly: the product was “you won’t have to pay the ransom,” and, per the indictment, the product was a lie. The client paid the ransom anyway, just with a middleman and a markup.

## The sting

The fun part is how the FBI checked. To catch a man accused of secretly standing between a victim and a hacker, the bureau played both of them.

In June, an undercover agent posed as a representative of a made-up Rhode Island business that said it had been hit by ransomware. A second FBI employee posed as the ransomware gang: they actually encrypted several files on a computer belonging to the fictitious company and left a ransom note with contact details. The fake victim then called Palacio’s company. At a first meeting on June 8, the agent said the business did not want to pay the ransom. Palacio later charged $2,750 for an initial forensic assessment and offered a contract for his company’s services.

On June 14, according to the indictment, Palacio emailed the “ransomware gang” (the FBI) asking for the “lowest possible price for the decryptor,” and accepted an offer of 0.2 bitcoin, then worth about $13,000. Two days later, his associate told the “victim” (also the FBI) that the files could be decrypted for $13,260. The FBI paid. The next day Palacio went back to the “hackers” (the FBI) and asked to cut the price from $13,000 to $4,000. The FBI’s pretend extortionist countered at $6,000.

So you have a man haggling with the FBI on behalf of the FBI, trying to widen his margin between two branches of the same federal agency. The FBI, playing a criminal, negotiated a better deal than the FBI got playing a customer, which seems about right.

![A person sits facing two empty chairs across a table with a key on it, against a red background.](https://rews.cc/img/af4e9ae3633da8b32afe935a0bedb0379083b2a0.webp)

On June 19, Palacio paid 0.0948 bitcoin, worth $6,003 at the time. Five days later the undercover agent handed over the decryption key. The indictment puts Company A’s profit from the sting at $10,010. The arithmetic: $13,260 for the decryption minus $6,003 for the key is $7,257, which on its own [doesn’t match the indictment’s figure](https://runtimewire.com/article/fbi-posed-as-ransomware-victim-and-attacker-in-sting-on-florida-recovery-firm). Add the $2,750 assessment fee and you get $10,007, within a few dollars of it. My guess is the fee is part of the total and the gap is bitcoin rounding, but that’s my reading and not the indictment’s.

## The real ones

The sting is the cute part, but the indictment also lists actual victims, real companies. One of them, a Kansas business, was allegedly charged $720,000. Prosecutors say Palacio paid a ransomware gang about $445,000 in bitcoin for the key and kept the rest, which works out to roughly $275,000. That is a markup of around 62%, on a service the client had hired specifically so it wouldn’t have to pay the hackers. If he is convicted, Palacio would have to forfeit the proceeds and any property obtained through the alleged fraud.

I think the interesting thing is how well this setup hides itself. Ransomware is a weird market: a victim negotiating with an anonymous extortionist can’t easily compare prices, can’t see what its agent pays, and mostly wants its files back and the whole thing to be over. If the recovery firm sends back a working key, the client has nothing to complain about and no way of knowing how the key was obtained. Every incentive pointed toward paying the hackers and keeping the spread, and the only way to see the spread was to stand on both sides of it. Which is what the FBI did.

![A document passes through a black magician’s hat, with a yellow arrow pointing down to a database inside.](https://rews.cc/img/f02b7f49d9792ef268c75316cef2e80f5567bf60.webp)

It’s also not the first time the people who clean up after ransomware have been charged with profiting from it. In April, Angelo Martino, a former negotiator at the incident-response firm DigitalMint, [pleaded guilty](https://www.helpnetsecurity.com/2026/04/21/ransomware-negotiator-blackcat-alphv-group/) to conspiring with the BlackCat ransomware gang. According to the Justice Department, he passed the gang “confidential information about the negotiating position and strategy of his company’s clients” to drive up ransom payments, including details like clients’ insurance policy limits. Martino also admitted to working with two other cybersecurity professionals to deploy ransomware against U.S. victims themselves. “Ransomware victims turned to this defendant for help, and he sold them out from the inside,” U.S. Attorney Jason A. Reding Quiñones said, [according to Insurance Journal](https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2026/04/27/867221.htm). Martino faced a maximum of 20 years.

The two cases aren’t the same. Martino admitted to helping the extortionists, while Palacio is accused of lying to his clients about what he was doing and taking a cut. Both, though, point to the same weakness: a victim in a ransomware crisis has to trust someone it can’t really check, in a market built on crime, and every so often the person it trusts turns out to be arbitraging the crime. Ransomware has already built [some elaborate machinery](https://rews.cc/a/the-ransomware-gang-that-rents-a-tiny-apartment-inside-your--ff9264); a recovery industry was always going to grow up around it, and so were its own frauds.

Anyway, the FBI now has a decryption key it sold to itself, $13,260 it paid out as a victim and $6,003 it took in as a criminal. On the books, that’s a loss of $7,257 for the government’s ransomware business.
