Countries sometimes regret their choices slowly. It can take years, and the people who made the choice and the people who now regret it are not always the same. A decade after Britain voted narrowly to leave the European Union, the kingdom is showing what Simon Speakman Cordall, writing for Al Jazeera, calls every sign of buyer’s remorse. For many people the campaign itself was ugly and divisive, and the divisions have outlasted it.

On Friday, 20 November, Prime Minister Andy Burnham went to Brussels for a summit with the bloc’s leaders. Reuters reported that Downing Street announced afterwards that the two sides had “agreed a reset deal and concluded negotiations.” What they agreed was a set of timelines for three things: a youth mobility scheme, a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement on food and agricultural standards, and a link between the British and European emissions trading systems. The details were to come later in a joint statement. The reset has been sealed while Brexit’s largest question stays open.

An inheritance

Labour inherited Brexit from the Conservatives. It won power in 2024 under Keir Starmer, who promised to “make Brexit work”. His method was technocratic: small agreements, regulations aligned one at a time, trade frictions eased bit by bit. As CNN’s Issy Ronald reported, that caution, on Europe and on much else, was a large part of why his own party removed him this summer. Burnham, more confident and more at home in front of cameras, took his place.

The Brussels summit belonged to the old government as much as the new. It had been planned for earlier in the year and was postponed when Starmer’s premiership fell apart. Nick Thomas-Symonds, Starmer’s Europe minister, told CNN the deal was “90% there” when Burnham’s team arrived. The remaining ten percent was the hard part. Would EU students pay the same tuition fees as British ones? How many young people would the mobility scheme admit? Where would Britain stand on the EU’s “Made in Europe” initiative, which threatens to push British firms out of European supply chains? Before the summit it was unclear whether those questions would move at all.

The new man changed the tone. In his first major foreign policy speech on Monday, Burnham said: “The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough.” He meant the 2020 agreement under which Britain left. Last month he said he would like to see Britain rejoin within his lifetime, but not in this parliament. He also ruled out crossing the red lines in Labour’s 2024 manifesto: no return to the single market, no customs union, no restored freedom of movement. After the summit he promised talks with Brussels “about options for our long-term relationship”, without saying what they would cover or when they would happen.

Same policy, new words

Anand Menon, a professor at King’s College London who directs the think tank UK in a Changing Europe, says Burnham’s actual approach has not changed “an iota” from Starmer’s.

“The only difference is how we talk about the future, and Burnham saying we might consider rejoining. The more people talk about rejoining, the more obviously complicated an undertaking it becomes. I don’t know where Burnham goes on this.”

Without giving ground on the red lines, Menon said, little more is likely to change. Earlier this month Michel Barnier, once the EU’s Brexit negotiator, warned that Britain cannot “cherry pick” pieces of the single market. Thomas-Symonds named other ways to get closer without breaking promises: cooperation on immigration, stronger military ties, regulatory alignment in more sectors. “Obviously, these bigger points are ones that we’re looking at in the next manifesto,” he said.

So far the reset has produced little, apart from Britain’s agreement to rejoin the Erasmus student exchange next year, at a much higher price than it used to pay. Menon said the government “really needs” the three summit deals, because without them “it’s going to look ridiculous.”

Sovereignty or trade

Economists broadly agree that leaving cost Britain growth, with estimates of lost output ranging from 2% to as much as 8%. A government looking for anything that might restart the economy has turned back to the EU, its largest trading partner and nearest neighbour. Burnham says the new agreements could add up to 0.4% of GDP and cut paperwork for food exporters.

The cost is the one that ran through the whole Brexit quarrel. Europe Minister Hamish Falconer conceded to the BBC that putting the deals into effect would oblige Britain to accept EU product rules without any say in writing them. Ten years after the vote, the choice between sovereignty and frictionless trade has not been settled. Each government faces it again.

Old soldiers

The words alone were enough to mobilise the other side. This week two campaign groups, both with links to the original Vote Leave campaign, launched or rebranded with one purpose: to fight any attempt to rejoin. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch accused Burnham of having “not learnt the lessons of the past”, arguing that “the problems this country faces today have nothing to do with being in or out of the EU.” Nigel Farage, the architect of Brexit, who now leads the hard-right Reform UK, said Burnham “has no mandate” to seek closer ties with Brussels. David Cameron and Boris Johnson, the two Conservative prime ministers whose time in office the divorce defined, have also warned him against reopening old wounds.

There is an irony in this. The men who opened the wound now warn against touching it.

Wanting it, and dreading it

Then there are the voters. Morgan Jones, deputy director of Persuasion UK, which studies public opinion, said polling suggests that if “there were an option to rejoin on 2016 terms tomorrow, it would be resoundingly popular”, including among the different groups of voters Labour would need for a majority. The road back is another matter. “We found that people were put off by the prospect of budget contributions or any threat of joining the Euro and also simply by the process itself – there is significant voter exhaustion on this topic,” she said, citing research done with a pro-EU think tank.

Many people would like to have gone back. Far fewer want to make the journey.

Brussels has its own memory of the break. Last week Kaja Kallas, the bloc’s foreign policy chief, said the EU had suffered “a lot of trauma” from Britain’s departure, and warned that any future negotiations “will not be that easy.”