Some nights in a country’s history last only a few hours and then take years to finish. The night of December 3, 2024, when President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law over South Korea, lasted about six hours before opposition lawmakers moved to reverse it. In the courts it is still going on. On Thursday, November 19, 2026, the Supreme Court in Seoul took up the part played that night by Han Duck-soo, Yoon’s prime minister, and cut it into two halves: the hours before the decree and the hours after.

As Al Jazeera reported, the court threw out the 15-year prison sentence imposed on Han, now 77, and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court. That court must now try it again under the Supreme Court’s own reading of what insurrection means.

Before the decree

The question that split the justices was a meeting, or rather the proposal of one. Before Yoon spoke to the nation, Han suggested convening the Cabinet. The lower courts treated this as a way of dressing the president’s decision in legitimacy, as if a room full of ministers could turn a coup into an act of state. A majority of the justices found that assessment wanting. Given how urgent the moment was, they said, it was hard to establish that Han had intended to subvert the Constitution in the hours before the declaration.

A blank illuminated panel casts a long shadow across a dark, ornate room, with the Capitol visible through a moonlit window.

The Seoul Economic Daily described the remand as coming with a partial acquittal opinion. The Seoul High Court will look again at the gravest charge, that Han played a key role in an insurrection, and both the verdict and the length of any sentence may change.

After the decree

The second half of the night did not go the same way. According to The Korea Times, the court let stand the findings about what Han did once martial law was in force: trying to collect Cabinet members’ signatures on a martial law document, and reviewing how to carry out Yoon’s order to cut power and water to certain media outlets. In the account carried by ThePrint, the justices agreed with the appeals court that by then Han had shown an intent to “subvert constitutional order”.

Here is the bureaucrat’s tragedy, seen in its plainest form. One reflection the record invites: under an order, the man who doubts and the man who obeys can look exactly alike for a time, until the paperwork starts. A signature on a decree is evidence. A hesitation leaves nothing behind.

Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae read out the ruling at a hearing broadcast live, and on the decree itself he allowed no ambiguity. The declaration, he said, was “not aligned with the constitutional order and violates the basic rights of the people”, adding: “there is no question on its unconstitutionality and illegality.”

A giant fountain pen casts the shadow of prison bars across a stone plaza in front of a courthouse.

Han is not going home. The ruling came one day before his detention period was due to run out, and the surviving convictions appear to be what keeps him held. He has been in the Seoul Detention Center in Uiwang since January.

Twenty-three, fifteen, unknown

His sentence has shrunk at every step up the judicial ladder. Special counsel Cho Eun-suk’s team indicted him in August 2025; Han had briefly served as acting president after Yoon was removed. On January 21, 2026, a district court gave him 23 years, saying his involvement threatened “the constitutional order” and amounted to insurrection. In May the Seoul High Court reduced the term to 15 years, acquitting him of some charges, including failing to stop the martial law attempt, and citing his “more than 50 years as a public official prior to the martial law declaration.” In August the Supreme Court referred the case to its full bench, on the grounds of strong public interest and historical significance. Now the number is unknown again.

The special prosecution team said it respects the court’s decision. Han denies every charge except one count of perjury. Last year he said he regretted being unable to stop Yoon, but that he “never agreed to it or tried to help.”

A horizontal wooden hourglass contains sand and a small locked prison door inside one glass bulb.

The other cells

The same day, the Supreme Court upheld the sentence of Kim Keon Hee, the former first lady, according to the Korea JoongAng Daily. Yoon himself was removed from office by the Constitutional Court in April 2025 after his impeachment; Lee Jae Myung won the presidency two months later. In February a Seoul district court convicted Yoon of leading an insurrection and sentenced him to life in prison. He denies wrongdoing, says he was using his lawful powers as president, and has appealed; that ruling is scheduled for January 26.

Others from that night are still moving through the courts, among them the lawmaker Choo, for whom prosecutors sought a 20-year term in September. The country has done this before. A month before Choo’s hearing, prosecutors in another courtroom were asking to uphold a death sentence in the retrial of the man who killed Park Chung-hee, a case from 1979 that still has not closed.

Han Duck-soo will go back to the Seoul High Court charged over a night that, for the law, now splits at the moment the decree was read: one half still open to doubt, the other already settled.