Power that fears a verdict has an old habit, and it is not to argue the case. It changes the judge. On November 4, one day before Somalia’s Supreme Court was due to decide whether President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud had lawfully added a year to his term, the presidency dismissed Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed. As Faisal Ali reported for Al Jazeera, the stated reason was complaints about the administration of justice.

The presidency said those complaints had come from judges, judicial staff and legal professionals. It named Ibrahim Idle Suleiman as the replacement, according to allAfrica. He had held the office before. In May 2018, then-president Farmaajo dismissed Suleiman and put Bashe in his place. Eight years later the clock was simply wound back. The case Bashe was meant to hear had been brought by a former president, Sharif Sheikh Ahmed.

The court sat anyway.

On November 5, five judges ruled that the constitutional amendments lengthening presidential and parliamentary terms from four to five years could not apply retrospectively to people already in office. The mandates, they said, had run out: Parliament’s on 14 April 2026 and the federal government’s on 15 May 2026, according to the judgment as reported by allAfrica. The court left the government only routine caretaker duties. It threw out the part of Sharif’s petition attacking the amendment process itself, finding he lacked standing to bring it. It also declared the chief justice’s dismissal null and void, saying the president had no constitutional power to remove him alone and accusing the presidency of trying to block the case.

Accounts of what the judges then ordered differ. UN human rights experts say the court ordered elections within 90 days. The Associated Press, which reviewed the judgment, reported that political leaders were given 30 days to agree on how to hold elections, and that the court neither named a replacement president nor said what would follow if the deadlines were missed.

The answer from Villa Somalia

The government rejected the ruling. Suleiman was sworn in on 7 November. The Ministry of Justice said the dismissal followed the applicable transitional procedures and had nothing to do with cases before the court, and that it would not treat anything Bashe signed after his removal as binding.

On November 12, UN experts said the removal by presidential decree “did not follow constitutional procedures, including approval by Parliament or a proposal from the Judicial Services Commission.” They said the government had ignored the court’s orders and sent hundreds of security personnel to the Supreme Court to disrupt and intimidate it. Seven judges, they said, had lost their personal security protection, despite the dangers they face, and had been barred from travelling. The experts called for Bashe to be reinstated.

The official calendar has not moved. Parliamentary elections are set for April 15, 2027, and the parliamentary vote for president for May 15, a timetable built on the five-year terms the court said do not apply.

A state made of bargains

The quarrel over one year is really a quarrel over thirty-five. After the central government collapsed in 1991, clan-based regional administrations raised their own institutions, forces and revenue. Somaliland declared independence that year, and Puntland became autonomous in 1998. The 2012 provisional constitution drew a federal frame around all this but put off the hardest questions about powers and resources. Since then Somalia has been governed by endless negotiation, and elections by deals among regional leaders and clan elders.

Parliament passed the first amendments in 2024 and the rest in March 2026, ending a 14-year review. They give Mogadishu more authority over collecting and sharing revenue, over elections and over intervening in member states. Citizens will elect the lower house directly, but parliament will still choose the president. State Minister for Foreign Affairs Ali Mohamed Omar argues that selection by clan elders left governments without public legitimacy, and calls the parliamentary presidential vote a compromise to win over parts of the opposition. The academic Afyare Elmi reads it differently: “Hassan Sheikh always wanted a Mogadishu-centred federal state, with no real federal substance.”

Puntland rejected the 2024 amendments and stopped cooperating with Mogadishu. Jubaland followed after a fight over electoral law. Both have their own forces and their own money. Jethro Norman of the Danish Institute for International Studies sees the system “crystallising into two camps”, with the regions holding that the 2012 bargain cannot be rewritten “through a parliamentary majority in Mogadishu when the regions have rejected it.” Puntland’s president, Said Abdullahi Deni, has warned that without a settlement, “Somalis must deliberate and decide on another alternative way to live together.”

In South West state, Mogadishu refused to recognise President Abdiaziz Hassan Laftagareen’s re-election in March, and federal troops removed him. His loyalists have since seized towns around Baidoa and fought government forces. In May the state held Somalia’s first direct election for a state assembly, which in June chose a Mohamud ally, Sheikh Adan Mohamed Nur Madobe, as president. From exile in Nairobi, Laftagareen says power-sharing “saved and kept Somalia together.” Mohamud’s allies now lead four of the six states. The lawmaker Mohamed Ibrahim Moalimuu admits those votes “weren’t totally free and fair”, and calls them a first step.

In June, government forces fought militias guarding a former president and a former prime minister, and part of the capital was paralysed for two days. In January Mogadishu cancelled the United Arab Emirates’ port and security agreements across the country, and the regional states refused to accept the decision. Since Israel recognised Somaliland at the end of 2025, the question of who controls the coast has only grown sharper.

Fewer guarantors

The Somali Future Council, a coalition of former presidents and prime ministers, turned down Mohamud’s offer of talks in November. Its spokesman, Mohamed Mahmoud Dirie, said its request for an international guarantor had been refused. There are fewer outsiders left to play that role. At the government’s request, the UN political mission closed in October. The African Union force fighting al-Shabab faces gaps in its funding, Uganda is pulling out its troops, and humanitarian aid is shrinking. Mahad Wasuge of Somali Public Agenda warns that the country is going through several transitions at once while “the trust between elites is low.”

Elmi calls this “one of the most dangerous times the Somali political system has faced.” Somalis, he says, “are no longer moving in the same direction.”