Households that buy tap water from investor-owned companies paid an average of $823 for a year of indoor use in 2025, $329 more than customers of public systems, according to a survey of the country’s 500 largest water systems that Food & Water Watch released on Tuesday.
That 67 percent premium is the number the group, which campaigns against private ownership of water systems, wants legislators to remember. It isn’t new. A decade ago the same group found that private companies charged households $501 a year for 60,000 gallons, $185 more than local governments charged for the same water, a 59 percent gap. The average public system’s bill in 2025, $494, was still lower than the average corporate bill back then.
Ownership can’t explain the climb. Typical household drinking water bills rose an average of 62 percent from 2015 to 2025, the report found. Over the same decade consumer prices rose 39 percent, grocery prices rose 30 percent, and median household income grew more slowly than water bills. Systems that stayed public raised bills by an average of 62 percent. Corporate systems raised them by 67 percent.
Rate filings, court records, federal spending data and a decade of academic work show two separate things inside those numbers. The private premium is real. It holds up under statistical controls in independent research, and it comes from how regulated companies make money: an allowed return on shareholders’ capital, taxes that city utilities don’t pay and, in Pennsylvania and seven other states, purchase prices that customers repay through their rates. The decade’s rise in everyone’s bill has other causes. The main ones are old pipes, new federal health rules, heavier debt payments and a federal government that covers about 4 percent of what the country spends on water and sewer utilities. Deferred maintenance shows up mostly in public systems, which pay for it years later in sudden rate increases.
What the survey measured
Food & Water Watch priced the same household everywhere: 60,000 gallons of drinking water a year through the smallest meter, at rates in effect in December 2025. It gathered the rates from utility websites, local ordinances and calls to customer service, and it left out sewer and stormwater charges. The group could compare 452 systems in both 2015 and 2025, according to its methodology. Common Dreams reported the findings along with the group’s call for state and local governments to ban privatization outright.
Prices varied tenfold. San Jose Water Company, a private utility, charged $1,416, the highest bill in the study. The public system in Hempstead, N.Y., charged $133, the lowest. Corporations ran 11 percent of the systems surveyed but 44 percent of the 25 most expensive and seven of the top 10. All 25 of the cheapest systems were public. Mary Grant, the group’s water policy director, named two causes:
Rampant corporate control of our water systems and federal disinvestment in aging infrastructure are driving up bills, forcing households to pick up the tab
The group’s comparison is a simple average, with no adjustment for system size, water source or region. For that, the group relies on a 2022 paper in Water Policy by Xue Zhang and Mildred Warner of Cornell University, Marcela González Rivas of the University of Pittsburgh and Ms. Grant herself. The authors used the group’s 2015 data on the 500 largest systems, 58 of them investor-owned. After controlling for system size and age, source water, drought, poverty and state regulation, they found that private ownership had the largest effect on bills, about $144 a year, Cornell said when the paper was published. Prices were higher still in states whose regulators favor private providers. One of the four authors works for the group that publicized the result.
Researchers outside the campaign find much the same thing. Manny Teodoro, a political scientist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison who studies how utilities set prices, wrote in a 2023 analysis on his blog that investor-owned utilities still charge substantially more on average than their local government peers. He drew on four waves of nationally representative rate data.
That public-private difference persists in models that adjust for size, source water, and region.
A 2023 study in PLOS Water, led by Ahmed Rachid El-Khattabi of the University of North Carolina’s Environmental Finance Center, looked at 1,558 systems in Arizona, Georgia, New Hampshire and Wisconsin. It found that city-owned systems were more likely to have lower bills than for-profit ones. Special districts and county authorities, which are also public, did not differ significantly from the for-profits.
Where the premium comes from
Pennsylvania American Water’s latest rate case shows how the math works. On July 16 the state Public Utility Commission voted 4 to 1 to approve a $74.9 million annual increase, less than half of the nearly $160 million the company had sought. The order set an allowed return on equity of 9.55 percent on a rate base of $6.6 billion, 54.23 percent of it financed with shareholders’ equity, according to American Water’s quarterly filing. The new rates took effect Aug. 13. The company said they add about $3 a month to a typical residential water bill.
Simple arithmetic on those three figures gives an equity stake of about $3.6 billion and roughly $340 million a year in after-tax profit that the commission allows the company to try to earn. The company isn’t guaranteed to earn it. The commission counts about 810,000 customers, homes and businesses together, so the allowance works out to about $420 per customer a year. A city-owned system has no shareholders to pay. Its cost of capital is the interest on its bonds.
Taxes add another layer. Investor-owned utilities pay property taxes on their land and buildings and recover them through rates, Dr. Teodoro wrote in a 2021 post against taxing tap water. He wrote that in New York American Water’s Nassau County territory, property taxes take as much as 30 to 50 percent of what customers pay. In one year, according to the post, the company paid $19.5 million in town and village taxes and another $23.5 million in school taxes.
Bill Ferguson, a co-founder of Keep Water Affordable, a Pennsylvania group that opposes sales of public systems, estimated that a little under 60 cents of each dollar customers pay Aqua or American Water covers the cost of supplying water and a little over 40 cents is pretax profit. The estimate is his own and could not be independently verified. He said in a Food & Water Watch release on Pennsylvania:
It is baked into the financial structure of the for-profit company.
The setup also rewards construction. Profit is a percentage of invested capital, so a bigger rate base produces bigger earnings. American Water’s estimated rate base grew from $16.3 billion in 2021 to $25.3 billion at the end of June, according to its second-quarter results. The company plans to invest $19 billion to $20 billion from 2026 through 2030, and it targets rate base growth of 8 to 9 percent a year and earnings growth of 7 to 9 percent. About 70 percent of its 10-year plan goes to renewing pipes and plants. Customers would pay for that work under any owner. Under a private owner, they also pay a return on it.
Residents spoke before the commission ruled. ECTV recorded the Jan. 15 hearing in Scranton, the only chance for people in northeastern Pennsylvania to testify on the request in person.

The Pennsylvania test
Under traditional utility regulation, a company that buys a municipal system can put only the system’s depreciated original cost, its book value, into rates. Pennsylvania changed that on April 14, 2016, when Tom Wolf, then the governor, signed Act 12. The law lets investor-owned utilities recover a system’s appraised fair market value instead. The buyer and the seller each hire an appraiser approved by the commission, and the rate base is the lower of the purchase price and the average of the two appraisals, Essential Utilities explains in its annual report. The company lists seven other states with similar laws: Illinois, Indiana, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Virginia and Texas.
The first sale to close under the law was Limerick Township’s sewer system. Aqua Pennsylvania, Essential’s subsidiary, paid $75.1 million for it in 2018. That was 63 percent more than the system’s book value and $23 million more than the next-highest bid, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported. After the state’s Office of Consumer Advocate challenged the deal, Aqua agreed to put $64.4 million into rates. The consumer advocate projected that Limerick’s 5,400 customers would see an 84 percent increase, to $70 a month, once a rate freeze ended in 2020.
By the end of 2025 the commission had received 31 applications under the law and approved 25, City & State Pennsylvania reported. After the sales, rates in the acquired systems rose by 45 percent to 167 percent, the Inquirer reported in 2024. In East Bradford Township, a monthly bill went from $68.09 to $98.69. Patrick Cicero, then the state’s consumer advocate, testified to state senators that the fair market value rule would cost customers at least $85 million a year. He also said none of the approved deals had involved “troubled or nonviable” systems.
The new survey reflects the result. Corporate systems in Pennsylvania charged an average of $1,172 a year, 82 percent more than the $643 at local government systems, and four of the 10 most expensive systems in the country are corporate systems in the state. Mr. Cicero, now with the Pennsylvania Utility Law Project, told City & State last December:
All that it’s done is inflate the value of systems for these private companies.
Some sellers had been running their systems badly. Before Pennsylvania American bought Exeter Township’s municipal sewer plant, the plant spilled 4 million gallons of untreated sewage into the Schuylkill River. Customers’ bills there later rose from $43.11 to $114.93, and the company says it has invested $19 million in the system. In New Garden Township, sewer operating costs ran 16 percent above revenue over the five years before Aqua bought the system in 2020. The industry cites that gap as evidence that towns had been holding rates below cost.
Thom Chiomento of Pennsylvania American Water told City & State that purchase prices are not the main driver of higher bills. He said towns had kept rates too low “because they’re not charging the cost of service,” and added:
People in poor communities tend to suffer when their governments don’t have the ability to invest in them.
The courts have mostly sided with the buyers. On Dec. 16, 2025, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court unanimously reinstated the commission’s approval of Aqua’s $54.9 million purchase of East Whiteland Township’s sewer system. It held that the prospect of higher rates does not by itself make a sale contrary to the public interest. On May 28, the Commonwealth Court vacated the commission’s 2024 rejection of Pennsylvania American’s purchase of Brentwood Borough’s sewers, priced at about $19 million, and sent the case back for a new decision. That rejection had been the first under the law’s valuation process.
An old argument
Americans have argued over who should own waterworks for two centuries. Of the 16 waterworks operating in the United States in 1800, only one, in Winchester, Va., was publicly owned. As late as 1890, 56 percent of the country’s 1,878 waterworks were private, the economist Scott Masten wrote in a study of 19th-century utility ownership. Then cities began taking them over. Between 1890 and 1920, the share of water companies owned by municipalities rose from 43 percent to 68 percent, according to the economic historian Werner Troesken.
Water was the exception among utilities. Only 8 percent of electric power plants were publicly owned in 1890. Dr. Masten argued that cities and private companies kept fighting over extensions of service that the companies said they could not recover the cost of, and that municipal ownership ended those fights.
One early modern reversal came in Atlanta, which turned over operation of its water system to United Water in 1999 under a 20-year, $428 million contract. Mayor Shirley Franklin canceled it on Jan. 24, 2003, after a series of critical audits. By then the staff had fallen from about 700 to 300, according to Public Citizen. It was a management contract, not a sale. About 90 percent of households now get their water from public systems, The Lever reported, citing the Environmental Protection Agency, and that share is falling as towns sell.
The industry’s case
Jenn Kocher, a spokeswoman for the National Association of Water Companies, whose members serve nearly 40 million customers, told Inside Climate News that affordability “is a legitimate challenge for many households.” She said rising bills “reflect sector-wide cost pressures, not ownership models.” She said comparisons should consider reliability, compliance with water quality rules and the condition of the pipes, and should account for “actual household usage and customer assistance programs.” She had not seen the full report, which was under embargo.
On water quality, the companies have research on their side. The political scientists David M. Konisky and Dr. Teodoro, writing in the American Journal of Political Science in 2016, studied more than 4,200 water utilities from 2010 to 2013. They found that government-owned utilities violated the Safe Drinking Water Act more often than private ones and were less likely to be penalized for it. They argued that regulators go easier on fellow governments.
Geography also accounts for some of the most expensive bills. San Jose Water, the costliest system in the survey, has told investors that Valley Water, Santa Clara County’s public water wholesaler, supplies 40 to 50 percent of its water, according to a past annual report. The company also pays Valley Water a charge on the groundwater it pumps. In July 2025, Valley Water raised its treated-water price about 9 percent and its groundwater charge about 10 percent, according to an advice letter the company filed with California regulators. West Virginia had the highest average bill, $1,383. American Water owns the state’s two largest systems, and the report notes that a shrinking population leaves fewer customers to share fixed costs. David Lapp, Maryland’s people’s counsel, told Inside Climate News that “small privately-owned water systems in Maryland typically lack the customer base and financial resources” to provide reliable, affordable service.
The research doesn’t back the claim that private operators run water systems more cheaply. In a 2010 meta-regression, Germà Bel and Xavier Fageda of the University of Barcelona and Dr. Warner pooled the econometric studies of private water distribution and garbage collection. They found “no systematic support for lower costs with private production.”
Checked against the record, the industry’s strongest points hold up only in part. Government-owned utilities do violate federal drinking water law more often, and purchased water and shrinking populations explain some of the highest bills. But the premium survives controls for size, water source and region, both in Dr. Teodoro’s data and in the Cornell and Pittsburgh study. The “sector-wide cost pressures” Ms. Kocher cited explain the growth in bills, which was nearly the same for both kinds of owner. They don’t explain the gap in the bills themselves, which was already 59 percent in the group’s earlier survey.
It is harder to say which cause matters most, and no study has split the national premium among returns, taxes and purchase prices. Purchase premiums are large in fair market value states but a modest part of the business nationally. American Water spent $346 million on regulated acquisitions in the first half of this year, out of $1.8 billion it invested. Essential has added more than $548 million in rate base through acquisitions since 2015. The allowed return, by contrast, applies to every dollar in the rate base. Deferred maintenance cuts the other way. The clearest cases in the record, Exeter’s sewage spill and New Garden’s losses, are towns that put off spending, and that is how the companies explain bills that jump after a sale. Mr. Cicero’s testimony that none of Pennsylvania’s approved deals involved troubled systems undercuts that explanation for most of the state’s sales.
Why public bills rose too
Manchester Water Works, the city-owned utility in New Hampshire, shows how a public bill rises. From 2015 to 2023 its debt payments rose 75 percent and its spending on treatment chemicals rose 143 percent, according to the report. New Hampshire bills rose 177 percent over the decade, the steepest increase of any state. Oregon’s rose 114 percent, as Portland and the Tualatin Valley pay for resiliency projects through rates.
Pipes are the biggest cost. In April 2023 the Environmental Protection Agency’s latest needs survey put the 20-year cost of drinking water infrastructure at $625 billion. That was 32 percent above the previous estimate, and $420.8 billion of it is for distribution and transmission lines. The survey counted about 9.2 million lead service lines. The American Water Works Association puts the total need near $960 billion. A 2024 rule requires systems to bring two PFAS chemicals, PFOA and PFOS, down to 4 parts per trillion by April 26, 2029. On May 20 the E.P.A. proposed extending that deadline to 2031 for systems that apply and qualify. American Water alone has budgeted about $2 billion for PFAS treatment through 2030.
Washington pays for little of it. State and local governments accounted for 96 percent of public spending on water supply and wastewater facilities in 2023, the same share as in 2017, according to Congressional Budget Office figures summarized by Circle of Blue. The roughly $50 billion for water in the 2021 infrastructure law ran out on Sept. 30, according to Food & Water Watch. The White House’s 2026 budget proposed cutting the two state revolving funds that lend to water systems by $2.46 billion, to $305 million, an 89 percent reduction, Water & Wastes Digest reported.
Across utilities of every kind, Dr. Teodoro’s data show water prices rising 3.8 percent a year, leaving water 25 percent more expensive in 2023 than in 2017. Kristin Dobbin, an assistant professor of cooperative extension at the University of California, Berkeley, who was not involved in the report, pointed to general inflation, costly treatment chemicals and supply chains strained during the pandemic. “Certainly, it’s striking that they found just how quickly water costs have risen in the decade,” she told Inside Climate News.
Jackson, Miss., shows what deferred maintenance costs. After decades of postponed repairs and the collapse of its main treatment plant in 2022, the city’s public system was placed under a court-appointed manager. On Feb. 23, Judge Henry Wingate of Federal District Court approved a 12 percent rate increase to cover a $1.2 million monthly shortfall, Mississippi Today reported. Officials had told him fewer than 65 percent of customers were paying. He called the increase a “survival measure” and the situation a “tragic catch-22.”
What comes next
The largest pending decision is in Harrisburg. American Water and Essential Utilities plan an all-stock merger that would combine more than 4.7 million water and wastewater connections. The combined company would have an enterprise value of about $63 billion and would operate in 17 states under the American Water name, with headquarters in Camden, N.J. Shareholders approved the deal on Feb. 10, and regulators in Kentucky, Ohio and Virginia have signed off. Pennsylvania is where the two companies overlap most. There, administrative law judges reported on Aug. 28 that some of the parties had reached a settlement, and the companies asked the commission to approve it on Sept. 15, according to a securities filing. The judges will send a recommended decision to the commission.
Mr. Cicero has said it “doesn’t particularly bode well for consumers to have one mega-utility serving most of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.” House Bill 1964 would impose a 12-month moratorium on sales of public water and sewer systems and repeal Act 12’s valuation rules. It passed the Consumer Protection, Technology and Utilities Committee 15 to 11 on March 23 and the Appropriations Committee 24 to 13 on April 13. The full House has not voted on it.
The E.P.A. has said it expects to finish the PFAS deadline extension this fall, according to the agency’s hearing materials. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit heard arguments on Sept. 18 in the industry’s challenge to the 2024 rule. In Congress, the WATER Act, which would create a federal trust fund for water and sewer systems, has not moved since it was reintroduced in May 2025.
American Water says it expects the merger to close by the end of the first quarter of 2027. On Act 12, the regulators have said the decision belongs to the legislature. “There’s a need for something like Act 12, but there’s also a need for some control on it as well,” Kimberly Barrow, the commission’s vice chairwoman, told City & State last year. “We can’t change the act on our own.”

