---
title: "Pakistan Floats Splitting Four Provinces Into Up to 30"
description: "Ministers talk up a New Year consensus on new provinces; a think tank puts the recurring bill at up to $2.64bn a year"
author: "Luis Goa"
published: 2026-11-17T11:17:07Z
modified: 2026-11-18T02:06:32Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/pakistan-floats-splitting-four-provinces-into-up-to-30-1c995f
language: en
tags: ["politics", "pakistan", "provinces", "constitution", "referendum", "asia"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# Pakistan Floats Splitting Four Provinces Into Up to 30

*Ministers talk up a New Year consensus on new provinces; a think tank puts the recurring bill at up to $2.64bn a year*

By Luis Goa · November 17, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/pakistan-floats-splitting-four-provinces-into-up-to-30-1c995f

## In brief

- Defence minister Khwaja Asif says new Pakistani provinces could arrive by the New Year, with no formal plan yet
- Proposals range from splitting Punjab into 3 provinces to a 30-province stress-test model
- Creating a province needs two-thirds votes in both houses plus the affected province’s assembly under Article 239
- PRIME Institute estimates annual recurring costs of $169m-$203m (Punjab split) up to $2.2bn-$2.64bn (30 provinces)
- Coalition partner PPP rejects splitting Sindh; no bill, province count or timetable has been agreed

Pakistan’s defence minister, Khwaja Asif, told the private channel Geo News this week that “my own view is that New Year will see this, the new system also, God willing,” referring to a plan to carve the country’s four provinces into a larger number of smaller units, as [Al Jazeera reported](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/17/is-pakistan-about-to-carve-out-new-provinces-inside-the-controversial-plan). He added he had “no inside information at this time” on any formal process. Those two sentences, said back to back by the minister responsible for the armed forces, describe the entire state of the plan as of November 2026: officials are confident it is coming, and none of them can say how.

The number worth tracking is 4. That is how many provinces Pakistan’s constitution currently recognises: Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and Balochistan. The number that keeps changing is how many there should be instead. Interior minister Mohsin Naqvi, a close confidant of military chief Field Marshal Asim Munir, raised the idea publicly on July 30 at an Islamabad summit. Planning minister Ahsan Iqbal has floated 12 to 15. Asif himself has previously backed a figure as high as 12, provided the lines are drawn on administrative grounds rather than ethnic ones, and has argued that power concentrated in Lahore, Karachi, Quetta and Peshawar should move to smaller units, [Daily Times reported](https://dailytimes.com.pk/1578641/kh-asif-backs-creation-of-new-provinces-says-even-12-could-be-considered/). No draft bill, no agreed count, no timetable exists yet, which is the nut of Al Jazeera’s story: a lot of public confidence, no document.

![Scissors hover over a stylized map of Pakistan divided into colorful regions with dashed lines.](https://rews.cc/img/c25e13efc30cfec4af3c4fbe5945e29541f40b45.webp)

## What the constitution actually requires

Pakistan’s constitution has no dedicated procedure for creating a province; it only has Article 239, the general amendment mechanism, and that sets a high bar. An amendment needs two-thirds of each house: 224 of 336 National Assembly members, 64 of 96 senators. Under Article 239(4), if the amendment redraws a province’s boundary, the affected province’s own assembly must also approve by two-thirds — 248 of 371 seats in Punjab, 112 of 168 in Sindh. The ruling coalition does not have that margin without the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), and the PPP has already said no: Sindh’s assembly passed a resolution in September rejecting any division of the province, and President Asif Ali Zardari repeated that objection to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on November 14, Al Jazeera reported. PPP’s Syed Nasir Hussain Shah put the party’s scepticism in one line: “is making provinces like building a new housing society?” — and suggested each province should be left to decide for itself rather than be redrawn as a single national package.

Naqvi has floated a workaround: let the public decide by referendum. “If the people say they should not be made, I am 100 percent with them,” he said. Article 48(6) lets the prime minister refer a matter to a joint sitting of parliament, which could lead to a national vote, but the lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii told Al Jazeera a referendum “cannot be used as a substitute” for the Article 239 process and would not be binding. Pakistan has held three referendums since independence — 1960, 1984 and 2002 — and all three came under military rulers, Ayub Khan, Zia-ul-Haq and Pervez Musharraf respectively. The analyst Majid Nizami described the referendum as a “second option,” the constitutional equivalent of an emergency power, not a routine tool for redrawing internal boundaries. Asif has separately said the military establishment has not asked politicians to open this debate, though he also said he did not know what legal procedure would actually be used to create a new unit, [Arab News Pakistan reported](https://www.arabnews.pk/pakistan/pakistan-minister-hints-at-new-provinces-hopes-for-progressive-political-change-3007151).

**How a new province would have to be approved** The constitutional route under Article 239, as described by lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii

| From | To | How |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Federal cabinet drafts bill | National Assembly vote *(224 of 336 seats needed)* |  |
| National Assembly vote *(224 of 336 seats needed)* | Senate vote *(64 of 96 seats needed)* |  |
| Senate vote *(64 of 96 seats needed)* | Affected province's assembly *(e.g. 248 of 371 in Punjab)* |  |
| Affected province's assembly *(e.g. 248 of 371 in Punjab)* | President signs amendment |  |
| Federal cabinet drafts bill | Referendum route (disputed) *(Article 48(6), not legally binding per Jaferii)* | proposed shortcut |
| Referendum route (disputed) *(Article 48(6), not legally binding per Jaferii)* | Affected province's assembly *(e.g. 248 of 371 in Punjab)* | disputed status |

![How a new province would have to be approved. The constitutional route under Article 239, as described by lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii](https://rews.cc/img/f648bf4064eaa373c13c1c5cc1b65ebd24b3e9ff.webp)

Based on [Al Jazeera, citing lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/17/is-pakistan-about-to-carve-out-new-provinces-inside-the-controversial-plan)

## The arithmetic nobody running the numbers likes

The Islamabad think tank PRIME (Policy Research Institute of Market Economy) ran the only public costing exercise so far, published in the October 2026 edition of its journal *Prime Plus* and summarised in [the Express Tribune](https://tribune.com.pk/story/2638146/new-provinces-will-cost-more-than-they-deliver) and [ProPakistani](https://propakistani.pk/2026/10/30/new-provinces-could-cost-pakistan-rs-730-billion-annually-report/). It modelled two scenarios using district population and area data from the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics’ 2023 census. The modest one splits Punjab into three — Bahawalpur, a South Punjab combining the Multan and Dera Ghazi Khan divisions, and the remainder — taking the national count from four to six. PRIME puts the extra recurring cost of that at 46.9bn to 56.2bn rupees a year ($169m to $203m, at current exchange rates), not counting one-off costs like new assembly buildings, secretariats and official residences, and not counting a separate police force or full administrative secretariat for each new unit.

The second scenario is a stress test, not a proposal: treat every one of Pakistan’s 30 existing administrative divisions as its own province, 26 new units on top of the current four. PRIME prices that at 609.2bn to 730.3bn rupees a year ($2.2bn to $2.64bn). Using a 10 percent threshold — the share of a province’s own federal transfer that PRIME treats as a sustainable ceiling for running its core institutions (governor, chief minister, assembly, secretariat, high court) — 16 of the 30 hypothetical provinces stay under that line and 14 go over it. The smallest are worst hit: the core provincial structure alone would eat roughly 49 percent of Loralai’s allocation and 45 percent of Zhob’s, even on PRIME’s lower cost estimate, leaving little for anything the new province was created to deliver.

![Stylized government buildings with dark blue domes and yellow flags stand on gold coins against a teal background.](https://rews.cc/img/d875b0c4547496531fb9474118168cd278bdbf86.webp)

PRIME’s underlying point is structural, not just a big number: splitting a province does not create new federal revenue, it redistributes the same National Finance Commission (NFC) pool among more governments. Provinces currently take 57.5 percent of federal tax revenue between them — 8.64 trillion rupees ($31.2bn) this fiscal year — split Punjab 51.74 percent, Sindh 24.55 percent, KP 14.62 percent, Balochistan 9.09 percent, per Al Jazeera’s reporting. Every new capital, assembly and secretariat is paid for by thinning that same pool further, which is why PRIME recommends that any province-creation bill come with a formal costing of each proposed unit’s expected NFC share and revenue capacity before, not after, the boundary is drawn. The institute’s broader warning, carried in its Tribune op-ed, is blunt: creating more, smaller provinces inside the existing resource envelope “will most likely deteriorate the quality of public service delivery,” especially for the smaller ones — a concern sharpened by the fact that Pakistan is in the last year of its current IMF programme.

Splitting Punjab alone would also roughly expand the Senate, since Pakistan gives each province equal upper-house representation regardless of population: PRIME and Al Jazeera both put the resulting chamber at 142 seats, up from 96. None of the current proposals address the 1991 Indus Water Accord, which allocates river water by province; redrawing provincial lines without renegotiating that accord leaves water shares for any new unit undefined.

![Five gated beige channels converge on a winding blue river against an orange background.](https://rews.cc/img/d1ce996d9139c9b6cf8bad0fc2f2e8981bb57421.webp)

## Who wants it, and why

The coalition’s math depends on parties that disagree with each other for different reasons. The Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan, whose federal health minister Mustafa Kamal backs new units and specifically a separate Karachi province, admits the federal cabinet has not formally discussed the idea and that he does not know what number is actually proposed. The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz, Asif’s own party, has no official position: Punjab Assembly speaker Malik Ahmad Khan said it is a matter for the party leadership. Naqvi has tried to set the terms for all of them at once — “if they all agree, everything will happen... otherwise nothing will” — which is a precise description of a proposal with no veto-proof majority behind it.

Asif has also tried to pull the opposition in, urging Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf founder Imran Khan, [whose party still runs the KP provincial government from outside the Islamabad coalition](https://rews.cc/a/pakistan-s-imran-khan-is-in-jail-but-he-still-runs-a-provinc-c11649), not to resist the plan, arguing Khan had no “fundamental objection” to smaller provinces on administrative efficiency grounds and that backing the idea could reopen a path back into mainstream politics, [Arab News Pakistan reported](https://www.arabnews.pk/pakistan/pakistan-minister-hints-at-new-provinces-hopes-for-progressive-political-change-3007151). Kamal pointed to the calendar as the real constraint: Senate elections fall early next year and the federal budget follows in June, which is why officials keep naming December and the New Year rather than a specific bill number or session. Pakistan has been here before. The Punjab Assembly passed resolutions for a South Punjab province and a restored Bahawalpur province in May 2012, and the Senate passed a Bahawalpur Janoobi Punjab bill in March 2013 — it lapsed when that National Assembly’s term ended without a second reading in the lower house. The current round has more ministers talking and no bill at all. Whether a text reaches parliament before the Senate election clock runs out is the number to watch next, not the minister’s confidence that it will.

## See also

- [South Punjab Province movement](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Punjab_Province_movement) — en.wikipedia.org · Background on the decades-old campaign for a Seraiki-speaking province
