Gov. Kathy Hochul of New York declared a statewide disaster emergency over measles on Monday. It was the first such declaration by any state since cases began climbing in 2025, Reuters reported.

By Pennsylvania’s standards the numbers are small. By New York’s they are large. The state has recorded 108 cases this year through Oct. 3, according to Executive Order 65, and 92 of them have come since July 15 in what the order calls under-immunized rural communities across 18 counties. In all of 2025 New York counted 48. Across the state line, Pennsylvania’s health department reported 1,004 cases on Monday, the largest state outbreak in more than three decades.

New York’s school vaccine law is one of the strictest in the country. It has allowed no religious exemption since 2019, and federal data put kindergarten measles coverage at 98 percent. The outbreak has grown anyway, in places and among people that law was never written to reach: rural adults who were not vaccinated as children, and Amish schools that have refused the mandate and taken their fight to the Supreme Court. In Pennsylvania, where a parent can opt a child out with a signature, the same gaps run wider. Federal changes since 2025 left the measles shot’s recommendation in place. They also muddied Washington’s message, left state immunization programs with less money than they expected and set off a public fight over how to count the dead. The emergency order widens who may give the shot. It cannot make anyone take it.

What the order does

The order took effect Monday and runs through Nov. 4. It rests on the state’s Executive Law, which lets a governor temporarily suspend or modify statutes and regulations during a declared disaster, and it uses that power mostly on the rules about who may hold the needle. Registered nurses may now order measles tests. Pharmacists may vaccinate children as young as 2. Certified paramedics, advanced EMS providers and midwives working under physician supervision may give the MMR vaccine, Medical Daily reported.

Every MMR dose must be reported to the state or New York City immunization registry within 72 hours, and the order waives the usual rule that adults consent to being entered. Vaccination itself still requires the consent of the patient or a guardian. “After reviewing the latest data on measles cases in New York State, I am declaring a State Disaster Emergency to strengthen our ongoing efforts to confront this disease,” Ms. Hochul said. The state health commissioner, Dr. James McDonald, urged residents to “check their vaccination status and make sure that they and their families are protected,” Gothamist reported.

None of this is new. In September 2022, after an unvaccinated Rockland County adult was paralyzed by polio, Ms. Hochul signed Executive Order 21, which let EMS workers, midwives and pharmacists give polio vaccine and required providers to send immunization data to the state registry. In September 2025 she used another order to let pharmacists give Covid shots after the reconstituted federal vaccine committee left state pharmacy law with no recommendation to follow. The measles order applies the same tools to a disease the country has not seen at this scale since 1991.

The last time

The country’s last measles epidemic ran from 1989 to 1991, when more than 55,000 cases and 123 deaths were reported, according to the CDC’s surveillance manual. Most of the sick were preschool children in poor cities who had not gotten their first dose on time. New York City alone confirmed about 2,000 cases in 1991, according to CIDRAP, and Philadelphia had about 1,400 in its 1990-91 outbreak, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.

The response built the system that later wiped out domestic spread. In 1989 the federal advisory committee and the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended a second dose for every child. In 1993 Congress created the Vaccines for Children program to pay for shots for children whose families could not. The United States declared measles eliminated in 2000, and for the next quarter century it averaged about 180 cases a year, according to federal data.

The closest call came in 2019. Linked outbreaks in Orthodox Jewish communities in Brooklyn and Rockland County accounted for 934 of the 1,249 cases reported nationwide from Jan. 1 to Oct. 1 that year, according to the CDC, and they nearly cost the country its elimination status. The state declared its outbreak over on Oct. 3, 2019, just short of a year after it began.

NYC mayor issues public health emergency amid measles outbreak
A CBS News report from Brooklyn on the public health emergency New York City declared during the 2019 measles outbreak. Video: CBS Mornings · YouTube

That spring tested what emergency powers can do. On April 9, 2019, Mayor Bill de Blasio declared a public health emergency and ordered unvaccinated people who lived, worked or went to school in four Williamsburg ZIP codes to get the MMR shot, with $1,000 fines for refusing. Parents sued. Justice Lawrence Knipel of State Supreme Court in Brooklyn upheld the order nine days later, writing that “a fireman need not obtain the informed consent of the owner before extinguishing a house fire,” NPR reported.

Rockland County pushed further and lost. Its county executive, Ed Day, barred unvaccinated minors from public places for 30 days starting in late March 2019. On April 5 Justice Rolf Thorsen blocked the ban, finding that such emergency orders could not last more than five days and that 166 cases in a county of 330,000 over six months did not amount to an epidemic, STAT reported. Ms. Hochul’s order fines no one and bars no one.

Where the cases are

Otsego County had 20 cases as of the latest state count, Seneca 17 and Steuben 14, according to the state’s measles dashboard as reported by WAMC. On Monday Ontario County announced four confirmed cases, all in unvaccinated residents, WHAM reported. Lewis County’s 11 cases, also all in unvaccinated people, remain centered in one town. New York City has seven cases and is not considered an outbreak area.

Dr. McDonald described the pattern on Sept. 23. “We are generally seeing a couple of measles cases percolate every single day right now in rural New York,” he said, and about one in five patients was being hospitalized, News10 reported. Roughly 66 percent of the infections were in adults, he said, the reverse of the 2019 outbreak in the city, where most patients were children. Comparing New York with Pennsylvania, he said, “ours is much smaller, and I think ours will stay smaller,” pointing to higher vaccination rates.

Local rates are another matter. In late August, after four unvaccinated Steuben County residents tested positive, WSKG reported measles vaccination rates of 77.5 percent in Otsego County, 79.1 percent in Steuben and 80.4 percent in Tioga, against about 80 percent statewide. It was not clear which age group those county figures cover. They fall well short of the 95 percent the CDC says prevents outbreaks. The order and the governor’s office describe the affected places only as under-immunized rural communities.

The school law and its limits

On June 13, 2019, with the Brooklyn and Rockland outbreaks still running, Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed a bill ending the religious exemption from school vaccine requirements that New York had allowed since 1966. The Assembly passed it 77 to 53, one vote more than it needed, NPR reported. Only medical exemptions remain.

Among schoolchildren, the law did its job. In the 2025-26 school year New York’s kindergarten exemption rate was 0.1 percent, tied with California and West Virginia for the lowest in the country, and MMR coverage was about 98 percent, according to CDC data compiled by Johns Hopkins.

Some schools refused. On Dec. 15, 2022, Health Commissioner Dr. Mary T. Bassett fined three Amish schools a combined $118,000, at $2,000 per unvaccinated child: $52,000 for Dygert Road School near Canajoharie, $46,000 for Pleasant View in Heuvelton and $20,000 for Shady Lane in Clymer, Amish America reported. Amish parents and school officials sued in 2023 and lost at the federal appeals court in Manhattan. The Supreme Court sent the case back for another look in light of its parental-rights ruling in Mahmoud v. Taylor, and the appeals court stood by its decision in June. The families filed a new petition on Sept. 28. Hiram Sasser of First Liberty Institute, one of the firms representing them, said in a statement:

If New York wins, the Amish may be forced to flee the state after peacefully living there since the 1830s.

Hiram Sasser, First Liberty Institute, counsel to the Amish families, firstliberty.org

It was not clear whether any of this year’s cases are in those schools’ communities, and state officials have not said. The larger limit is arithmetic. A school mandate, however strict, reaches children enrolled in school. Two-thirds of New York’s patients are adults, whose vaccination status was settled long before 2019.

Next door in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania’s outbreak began in April west of Philadelphia. By Monday the state counted 1,004 cases in 39 of its 67 counties, 198 hospitalizations and five measles-associated deaths, according to state figures reported by Spotlight PA and CIDRAP. More than 99 percent of patients were unvaccinated. Only 32 percent were under 18.

Lancaster County, home to the country’s largest Amish community, about 44,000 people, had 391 cases, NBC News reported. The dead include two infants, a 20-year-old woman with leukemia who was on chemotherapy, a 40-year-old woman with asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and an 18-year-old who developed disseminated encephalomyelitis. None were vaccinated. Little has been released about the fifth, beyond that the person lived in Lancaster County.

Governor Shapiro, Secretary Bogen to Provide Update on Ongoing Measles Outbreak in Pennsylvania
Video of a measles outbreak update from Gov. Josh Shapiro and Health Secretary Dr. Debra Bogen of Pennsylvania in late August. Video: Governor Shapiro · YouTube

Pennsylvania lets parents opt out of school vaccines on medical or religious grounds or for “strong moral or ethical convictions,” one of 15 states with a philosophical exemption. In 2023-24, religious exemptions covered 2.5 percent of kindergartners and philosophical ones nearly 2 percent, according to an analysis of state data by Pennsylvania Partnerships for Children. Kindergarten measles coverage fell to 93.7 percent in 2024-25 from 95.5 percent six years earlier, Spotlight PA reported in May. CDC data put the state’s 2025-26 exemption rate at 6 percent, Axios reported.

Even counties near the target struggle. Chester County, at 94.5 percent coverage, had 84 cases. Dale Weiser of the county health department told The Inquirer that people hang up on contact tracers and are “absolutely not going to stay home for 21 days.” He said:

It’s very hard to stop it, especially without real cooperation from the community.

Dale Weiser, Chester County Health Department, inquirer.com

Providers gave 53,000 MMR doses in September, more than double the usual number, CIDRAP reported. Dr. Paul Offit of Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia has argued that the official count is far too low. Measles kills one to three of every 1,000 people it infects, so five deaths point to 5,000 or more cases, and many Amish families nurse sick children at home rather than see a doctor.

A fight over the dead

On Aug. 25 Gov. Josh Shapiro and the state health department announced Pennsylvania’s first two measles-associated deaths in 35 years. At a news conference in Lancaster County, Mr. Shapiro said the administration’s rhetoric was having “a negative impact” and that misinformation has “real-life consequences,” ABC News reported. The next day Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. wrote on X that the deaths might have been fabricated, NPR reported.

Governor Shapiro’s unseemly rush to Lancaster County to convene a national press conference and his giddy delight in announcing two measles deaths was a morose commentary on the contemporary political dialogue. The performance was a replay of the Democrats’ COVID playbook:…

Secretary Kennedy @SecKennedy on X · August 26, 2026

The record since then is mixed. According to posts by Mr. Kennedy and Lancaster County Commissioner Josh Parsons, the county coroner said the first infant, born at home, had tested positive for measles but died of a ruptured spleen. The coroner later said a second infant, who had a rare genetic condition and was in palliative care, did die of measles. The state counts both as measles-associated, a category it uses when there is laboratory or epidemiological evidence of measles, FactCheck.org reported.

Dr. Debra Bogen, the state health secretary and a pediatrician, answered Mr. Kennedy the day he posted, in a statement the department put on X:

“As a pediatrician with more than 30 years of caring for children, I have thoroughly reviewed the case investigation information and sadly can confirm that there were two recent measles-associated deaths in Lancaster County, which were reported to the CDC’s measles response team…

PA Department of Health @PAHealthDept on X · August 27, 2026

For weeks the CDC’s dashboard listed no measles deaths for the year. Mr. Shapiro said Mr. Kennedy had “personally intervened” to keep the Pennsylvania deaths off it. Mr. Kennedy denied that and said the agency applies its own standard for deaths caused by measles. Mr. Shapiro said on CNN that the state would turn down federal help until the dashboard changed. “I’m not going to accept that until RFK does what is right,” he said, WPSU reported. The CDC added one death about two weeks ago and a second last week, The Associated Press reported. Official tallies may undercount the toll in other ways as well.

The federal record

The federal recommendation that children get two doses of MMR has not changed. Much around it has. In June 2025 Mr. Kennedy fired all 17 voting members of the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. That September, the panel he appointed voted against the combined measles, mumps, rubella and varicella shot for children under 4. In January the CDC dropped universal recommendations for seven childhood vaccines, among them hepatitis B, rotavirus and RSV, and kept MMR, according to the New York attorney general’s office.

On March 16 Judge Brian Murphy of Federal District Court in Massachusetts stayed the January schedule, the new committee appointments and the panel’s votes in a suit led by the American Academy of Pediatrics, Pharmacy Times reported. The appeals court in Boston is weighing whether to lift that order. On Aug. 10 President Trump signed an executive order calling for MMR to be given as three separate single-disease shots once such products are available here. None are sold in the United States, and the pediatrics academy has estimated that developing them would take a decade.

Mr. Kennedy’s own words on the vaccine have moved around. FactCheck.org found no instance before April of his endorsing MMR without a qualification or a misleading claim attached. Asked at a House hearing on April 16 whether it was safe and effective, he said “Yes,” and then, “It’s safe for most people.” Before two Senate committees this spring he rejected any responsibility for the outbreaks, CIDRAP reported:

I have not visited Mexico or Europe. I have nothing to do with the measles outbreak.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr., secretary of health and human services, cidrap.umn.edu

Money pays for the clinics that do the vaccinating. In March 2025 the CDC canceled $11.4 billion in pandemic-era grants to state and local health departments, about $2 billion of it for immunization work, and New York was among the states whose immunization awards for fiscal 2026 came in lower than expected, according to CNN’s analysis of federal data. As of September the CDC had awarded $50 million in one-time measles response money, according to the Congressional Research Service.

New York has spent the year separating itself from Washington’s advice. In May Ms. Hochul signed bills that strip references to the federal committee from state health, education and Medicaid law and require insurers to cover vaccines the state health commissioner recommends, her office said. On Monday, the day of the disaster order, Attorney General Letitia James joined a suit against Mr. Kennedy brought earlier by 14 attorneys general and Pennsylvania’s governor. It challenges the January schedule, the committee firings and the end of the universal hepatitis B birth dose. Her office’s announcement did not mention measles.

The case against blaming Washington

Mr. Kennedy’s defense rests on dates, and some of them hold. He told senators that most unvaccinated Americans infected last year were older than 5, so their parents decided before he took office. National kindergarten MMR coverage fell from 95.2 percent in 2019-20 to 92.4 percent in 2025-26, a slide that began during the pandemic, according to KFF and the CDC’s measles data. And about two-thirds of patients in both New York and Pennsylvania are adults whose childhood shots, or lack of them, were decided decades ago.

Low coverage in Plain communities is old too. In 2014, 383 people caught measles in an Ohio outbreak that started with two unvaccinated Amish men returning from typhoon relief in the Philippines, according to a 2016 study in The New England Journal of Medicine led by Dr. Paul Gastañaduy of the CDC. Ninety-nine percent of the patients were Amish, and coverage with at least one dose was estimated at 14 percent in affected Amish households. Dr. John Goldman, an infectious disease specialist at UPMC, said the faith does not oppose vaccines but that Amish rates have long trailed the general public’s. He told NBC News that Lancaster is not unusual:

The exact same thing could happen in any county in the country that has a large percentage of unvaccinated people

Dr. John Goldman, infectious disease specialist at UPMC, nbcnews.com

The other side has evidence as well. Dr. David Hill, a spokesman for the American Academy of Pediatrics, said after Mr. Kennedy’s testimony that imported cases do not spread where coverage reaches 95 percent, and that anyone spreading vaccine misinformation “shares in the responsibility for these outbreaks.” Exemptions kept rising on Mr. Kennedy’s watch, to a record 4.2 percent of kindergartners in 2025-26 from 3.6 percent a year earlier, with increases in 41 states, according to CDC data.

Set side by side, the evidence supports a narrower claim than either camp makes. The pockets where measles is spreading now were open before 2025: in Amish and Mennonite settlements, in states that let parents sign away school requirements and among adults no school law reached. No study has measured how much federal policy since then has added. What can be documented is a federal government that spent the worst measles year since 1991 disputing a death count, ordering single-disease shots that do not exist and sending state immunization programs less money than they expected, while exemptions climbed.

What comes next

The Pan American Health Organization’s Regional Verification Commission meets in November to decide whether the United States and Mexico still meet its definition of elimination. The review was first set for April and then moved. For the United States the clock starts with the West Texas outbreak’s onset on Jan. 20, 2025, and the CDC counts 3,887 cases this year as of Oct. 1. Endemic spread is back, PAHO said in March, when there is:

uninterrupted circulation of the same virus genotype and lineage for 12 months or more in a specific geographic area

Pan American Health Organization, paho.org

Canada failed that test last year. PAHO revoked its status on Nov. 10, 2025, after an outbreak that began in New Brunswick in October 2024 ran past 12 months, CNN reported, and the decision cost the Americas its standing as a measles-free region. ProPublica has reported that genome sequencing traces a continuous chain from West Texas through Utah, South Carolina and at least four other states. Dr. Offit has reached his own verdict. “Measles is now endemic in the United States,” he told CIDRAP.

Other deadlines come sooner. The president’s August order gave the health department 90 days to present plans for single-disease measles, mumps and rubella shots. The Amish families’ petition is before the Supreme Court. The appeals court in Boston has set no date for its ruling on the January schedule. Dr. Goldman expects Pennsylvania’s outbreak to “go on for at least another three to six months.”

New York’s disaster emergency expires on Nov. 4 unless Ms. Hochul renews it. The commission that will decide whether the 2000 declaration still stands meets that same month.