On Wednesday Benjamin Netanyahu had a visitor, and nobody announced it. The task of forming Israel’s next government belonged to another man. The visitor was Naftali Bennett. In 2021 Bennett built the coalition that ended Netanyahu’s twelve unbroken years in power, and he had promised, as others in the opposition had, never to serve under him again. The two talked for two and a half hours. Netanyahu’s office called it a “security briefing”.
Inside the opposition alliance people used harsher words. Simon Speakman Cordall reported for Al Jazeera that its sources told Israeli media the meeting was a “strategic disaster”. Sources quoted by Ynet said Bennett had not warned Gadi Eisenkot, the bloc’s leader and the man charged with forming the government, beforehand. Channel 12 reported that Bennett then urged his fellow opposition leaders to explore a unity government with Netanyahu. A senior figure in the alliance told Ynet: “Netanyahu is trying to break up the [opposition] bloc for change through Bennett.”
The caretaker’s patience
What follows is reflection, not reporting. A ruler who has lost an election but still holds the office does not have to win the next round. He only has to wait for his opponents to fail to agree before the clock runs out. Netanyahu has kept the keys as caretaker since the October 27 vote and has disputed the result. The clock now reads December 6, the day Eisenkot’s mandate expires.

Five men, one shared past
The alliance is five men who met in the end because they agreed on one thing. They put it in writing in a pact signed in Yair Lapid’s Tel Aviv home. Several of them have sat at Netanyahu’s table. After the Hamas attack of October 7, 2023, Eisenkot joined Netanyahu’s emergency unity government as a minister without portfolio and a member of the war cabinet. Avigdor Lieberman was once his foreign minister and later his defence minister. Bennett was once a close ally, served as prime minister for the first half of the coalition he built with Lapid, and still shares many of Netanyahu’s policies.
All of them backed the Gaza war, at least at first, along with the strikes on Iran and Lebanon. At home they part ways. Eisenkot and Lapid, Bennett’s electoral partner, are seen as centrists. Bennett, a religious nationalist, and Lieberman, a secular politician whose base is the Russian-speaking community, are firmly on the right. Yair Golan of the Democrats is on the left. He supports a two-state solution and condemns settler violence in the West Bank, which he says the government either encourages or tolerates.
Thirteen seats
The numbers are simple. After the October 27 election the bloc holds 48 of the Knesset’s 120 seats and needs 13 more for a majority. As an earlier count made plain, every way of finding them breaks a promise someone made.

The first option is the parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel. Golan met their leaders and spoke well of their support. The rest of the bloc rejected the idea, and right-wing protesters threatened civil war over it. The second option is Shas and United Torah Judaism, the ultra-Orthodox parties, whose 13 seats are exactly the shortfall. Lieberman’s Yisrael Beytenu has 7 seats. He firmly refuses to depend on Palestinian votes, but his opposition to draft exemptions for the ultra-Orthodox appears to be softening. A deal there could break campaign promises and anger the voters who believed them.
The men have said hard things about one another. In August Bennett called Eisenkot’s plan for limited exemptions an “insane mistake” and warned that the ultra-Orthodox leaders Aryeh Deri and Moshe Gafni would “run circles around” him. Eisenkot replied that Bennett and Lieberman were practising “old politics” and hurting the opposition by refusing to accept that the alliance’s largest party should lead it. Weeks before the vote Lieberman called Eisenkot “Gantz 2.0”, recalling Benny Gantz’s move into Netanyahu’s government in 2020, and accused him of secretly seeking a deal with Netanyahu out of personal ambition. Days after the election Golan told Lieberman that if he wanted a government that would not draft the ultra-Orthodox, he was “welcome to form one with Netanyahu.”
Older words
There are older words too. In 2020 Bennett said he respected Netanyahu “very much”, that Israel had “won a victory” with his long tenure, and that he had “done great things.” In 2019 Lieberman told The Jerusalem Post he wished Netanyahu “only really good results” and hoped he would be acquitted of corruption. Since then Lieberman has cited those same charges again and again as proof that Netanyahu is unfit to lead.

Eisenkot’s wager
Eisenkot’s party, Yashar, has decided not to wait. Anna Barsky reported in The Jerusalem Post that Yashar will negotiate a national unity government with Likud but rejects any rotation with Netanyahu, so Eisenkot would serve the full term. If the talks with Likud and the ultra-Orthodox parties both fail, Yashar would form a minority government supported from outside by Ra’am and the Joint List. In the Bennett-Lapid government Ra’am was a formal coalition member. This time neither party would get ministries or seats in the security cabinet, though the government would still need their votes on major laws and on any vote that could bring it down.
We will not wait for the mandate to pass to Netanyahu and then from him to the Knesset
Yashar officials say the vote will come before the mandate expires “in any case”, and that neither the ultra-Orthodox talks nor Bennett’s separate initiative will delay it. The obstacles are real. It is not certain that Yashar’s own right-wing lawmakers will back the plan. Party sources expect them either to go along or to resign from the Knesset, but that is the officials’ expectation, not the lawmakers’ promise. Opposition from Yisrael Beytenu, together with possible abstentions by Arab lawmakers, could leave the government short of a majority. With Matan Kahana, who won the speaker’s vote, presiding, the procedure may be easier, but the speaker cannot supply the votes. Eisenkot may call the vote without knowing whether he has them.
That would leave the choice with Bennett and Lieberman. Before December 6 they may have to decide whether to let Eisenkot’s government take office or vote it down, and with it the effort to replace Netanyahu. On Wednesday one of them spent two and a half hours with the man they had all sworn to remove.
