---
title: "Kushner Says Russia Is ‘Comfortable’ With an Article 5 Guarantee for Ukraine"
description: "In Berlin, Europe asks for a seat at the table. Putin offers Moscow as the venue and promises retaliation over the Kerch Bridge"
author: "Nate Ledger"
published: 2026-11-19T19:40:23Z
modified: 2026-11-20T04:17:17Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/kushner-says-russia-is-comfortable-with-an-article-5-guarant-0eed5d
language: en
tags: ["nato", "russia", "ukraine", "trump", "politics", "world"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# Kushner Says Russia Is ‘Comfortable’ With an Article 5 Guarantee for Ukraine

*In Berlin, Europe asks for a seat at the table. Putin offers Moscow as the venue and promises retaliation over the Kerch Bridge*

By Nate Ledger · November 19, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/kushner-says-russia-is-comfortable-with-an-article-5-guarant-0eed5d

## In brief

- Jared Kushner said in Berlin that Russia is ‘comfortable’ with Article 5-style security guarantees for postwar Ukraine
- Kushner said Trump is open to the idea if it serves US interests and forms part of a broader security package; Russia has not commented
- Merz called the Trump-Xi-Putin summit in Shenzhen a ‘photo op’ and said peace talks can only succeed with Ukraine and Europe
- Putin said Europeans could join talks and suggested Moscow as the venue. Macron called for reopening Ukraine’s NATO accession
- Putin vowed to retaliate for the Kerch Bridge strikes. Dutch and Austrian embassies in Kyiv were damaged, with no one hurt

Here is a sentence that, if true, would be a big deal: “I think we’ve gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept where any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5.” Jared Kushner, Donald Trump’s son-in-law and peace envoy, said it in Berlin on Thursday after a meeting of the European “Coalition of the Willing,” [according to Al Jazeera’s wire roundup](https://aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/19/european-leaders-unite-in-berlin-to-reaffirm-support-for-ukraine). Article 5 is the clause in NATO’s treaty that treats an attack on one member as an attack on all of them. Russia has spent years describing NATO’s eastward spread as a reason for the war. So Russia being comfortable with a guarantee for Ukraine modelled on NATO’s core promise is either a real breakthrough or a very generous summary of a conversation. Russia has not commented.

The way to read a security guarantee is a bit like reading a credit guarantee. The words cost nothing to write. What matters is who is on the hook, for how much, and whether anyone expects them to pay. “Based on Article 5” is a description of the words. Kushner’s caveats are about who pays. Trump is “open” to the idea, he said, but “obviously it has to be in America’s interest” and it would have to be part of “a broader security package.” [The Kyiv Post quoted him](https://www.kyivpost.com/post/90644) going further: “From America’s perspective, giving an Article 5-like security guarantee is a really, really big deal.” He also conceded that there is “a lot of skepticism and disbelief on that concept in Russia,” which is hard to square with the word “comfortable.” Any guarantee, he said, should come with monitoring, verification and deterrence.

![A torn paper umbrella shelters a blue and yellow house from heavy rain.](https://rews.cc/img/f61c21f94e8fea8234bebbbc1c40e1bcaa2e827b.webp)

So Russia is comfortable with the concept, the US is open to the concept, and nobody has said what the concept is. Fine. That’s what the early stage of a negotiation looks like.

## Who gets a chair

The Berlin meeting came hours after an unprecedented three-way summit in Shenzhen between Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Europe was not invited, and Europe noticed. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz called Shenzhen a “photo op” and warned that any deal struck without Europe would fail: “if it comes to peace negotiations, then we will be involved,” and such talks “can only be successful with Ukraine and Europe.” He said he hoped to work as a “team with Kyiv and Washington” when talks with Russia happen. No date has been set.

British Prime Minister Andy Burnham said Europe is “ready to enter negotiations” and has “a clear and consistent and united negotiating position,” while insisting that “a peace agreement between Ukraine and Russia must come first.” He welcomed the US presence too: “This clearly has got to be a moment to move towards peace because of the US involvement that we’ve seen today and the progress clearly that is being made.” Kushner, for his part, offered the reassurance Europe wanted: “Trump wants to make a deal with Europe by his side,” and “We do believe that Russia having Europe at the table will be essential for ending the war.” [Xinhua reported](https://english.news.cn/20261120/ca123684f44a4fbe8f3adbeeb52934b4/c.html) that he said Moscow had agreed to European participation in a multilateral negotiating mechanism. He said Trump phoned into the Berlin talks after seeing Putin, and that last week’s round in Abu Dhabi produced no major breakthrough.

![Empty chairs surround a table printed with a map, with a Ukrainian flag resting on a blue chair.](https://rews.cc/img/ae67048440598f149ac2cb0212d7fa11beb06378.webp)

Putin, speaking in Shenzhen, said the Kremlin has no objection to Europeans joining the talks, and he even suggested a venue: Moscow. Russia had proposed through diplomatic channels that European officials come there “to determine their position,” he said, without naming a date. The [fight over the guest list](https://rews.cc/a/russia-disputes-the-guest-list-as-ukraine-talks-move-toward--6853bd) has become a fight over the address. Being invited to determine your position in your counterparty’s capital is an unusual kind of invitation.

French President Emmanuel Macron was the least interested in tidy concepts. “Faced with the maximalist nature of the Russian position, I believe we need to reopen the question of Ukraine’s accession to NATO,” he said. That is not an Article 5-style guarantee. It is actual Article 5, and Ukraine’s NATO membership is one of the issues holding up a deal. Macron also said that “everyone who has the capacity to provide the means to defend and protect Ukrainian citizens must do so now,” with anti-missile systems and interceptors first. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy wrote on X: “We do not want Russia to drag all of this out into the winter. Pressure is needed. Europe is ready with new sanctions and new steps to support Ukraine and the Ukrainian people. It is important that the United States of America exert its influence on Russia.”

## The bridge

While all this was going on, the Kerch Bridge, which connects occupied Crimea to the Russian mainland, was taking hits from [three Ukrainian aerial attacks this week](https://rews.cc/a/ukraine-brings-down-kerch-bridge-arch-using-relay-drones-not-eaa27e). Putin said its road section was “seriously damaged” but would be rebuilt. He described it as a civilian asset that he had ordered closed to military hardware and ammunition, and he said: “We will respond to these attacks, and I want everyone to be clear about that.” Train traffic resumed on Thursday afternoon, RIA Novosti reported. Ukraine’s Defence Ministry said Russia would now have to move fuel and ammunition by land, “where our drones are waiting for the cargo.”

![A freight train approaches a broken bridge over the sea, with a drone overhead and dashed routes crossing a textured, map-like background.](https://rews.cc/img/339116fd375b4c5ebb89fee6d849c61b8ac7089f.webp)

Then the Dutch company Destinus said its missiles were the only foreign-made weapons used in Tuesday’s strike. Its president, Oleksandr Danyliuk, said Ukraine launched nine of its RUTA missiles and seven hit, [according to IO+](https://ioplus.nl/en/posts/kerch-bridge-strike-dutch-firm-destinus-missiles-were-key). Defence contractors like to tell people their products work, and this one is very good marketing. It also gave Russia’s embassy in The Hague an opening. It said it was becoming “increasingly difficult to regard the Netherlands as a mere bystander,” and, [per the Guardian’s briefing](https://www.inkl.com/news/ukraine-war-briefing-russia-asks-if-netherlands-has-joined-conflict-after-crimea-bridge-strike), posted that “The confession has been well noted.”

On Thursday afternoon a projectile landed behind the Dutch embassy in Kyiv. No one was hurt, there was minor damage, and the Netherlands summoned Russia’s ambassador. Foreign Minister Tom Berendsen told RTL the incident was “unacceptable.” Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said Austria’s embassy was also hit, with no staff harmed, and Sweden said it would summon Russia’s ambassador over an explosion near its embassy, Reuters reported. Whether the Dutch incident had anything to do with the Destinus statement is unclear.

The fighting carried on overnight. Russia’s Defence Ministry said it intercepted 53 Ukrainian drones, and the governor of Russia’s Saratov region, Roman Busargin, said a Ukrainian attack killed three people there. Ukraine said Russian anti-ship missiles and 98 drones struck 18 locations, killing two people and wounding at least 23.

Berendsen had already set out the Dutch position, [according to Geopolitiki](https://geopolitiki.com/military/russian-embassy-asks-whether-netherlands-joining-war-destinus-ruta-missiles-crimean-bridge-berendsen-not-impressed/): Dutch companies selling weapons to Ukraine does not mean the Netherlands is at war with Russia. The line between supplying a country and fighting for it is exactly the line an Article 5-style guarantee for Ukraine would have to draw, in writing, before anyone signs.
