---
title: "In Berlin, a Promise to Protect Ukraine Meets an Old Question"
description: "Kushner says Russia could accept Article 5-style guarantees; analysts doubt Western allies would pledge to fight for Ukraine"
author: "Jan Sokol"
published: 2026-11-20T11:01:51Z
modified: 2026-11-20T14:17:50Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/in-berlin-a-promise-to-protect-ukraine-meets-an-old-question-b42b25
language: en
tags: ["politics", "trump", "russia", "ukraine", "nato", "world"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# In Berlin, a Promise to Protect Ukraine Meets an Old Question

*Kushner says Russia could accept Article 5-style guarantees; analysts doubt Western allies would pledge to fight for Ukraine*

By Jan Sokol · November 20, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/in-berlin-a-promise-to-protect-ukraine-meets-an-old-question-b42b25

## In brief

- Kushner said in Berlin that he believes Russia is comfortable with NATO-like post-war security guarantees for Ukraine
- The proposed model is based on NATO’s Article 5 mutual-defence principle
- Analysts questioned whether the US and Europe would commit to defending Ukraine against another Russian attack
- European governments backed Zelenskyy’s refusal to cede territory, according to a separate report

At a meeting with European leaders in Berlin on Thursday, Jared Kushner offered a word that diplomats use when the heavier machinery of state has not yet moved: “comfortable”. President Donald Trump’s envoy and son-in-law said he believed Russia was comfortable with NATO-like security guarantees for Ukraine after its war with Moscow, now approaching the five-year mark, finally ends. The proposal, as Al Jazeera reported, is intended to secure the peace rather than merely name its arrival.

Kushner’s formulation was important. It was his assessment of Russia’s position, not a public commitment by Moscow to the plan. [CNBC reported](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/20/kushner-ukraine-nato-russia-trump-putin.html) that he said Russia might accept such guarantees and that Trump wanted to end the full-scale invasion “with Europe by his side”. Europe, in this telling, is asked to stand beside Washington both in ending the war and in underwriting what follows.

The model is NATO’s Article 5, under which an attack against one member is regarded as an attack against all. Applied to Ukraine without necessarily making Ukraine a NATO member, it would turn post-war security into a promise with consequences: a future Russian attack could require a military response from the guarantors.

![Five hands hold a torn paper shield against a blue background, with blue sky and yellow wheat fields at its base.](https://rews.cc/img/f8b0daa942498a4508146bc3e42f5e0e6de1e3f3.webp)

## The distance between paper and an army

That is where the analysts cited by Al Jazeera placed their doubt. They argued that the notion of the United States and European governments obligating themselves to defend Ukraine against a future Russian attack — the substance of Article 5 — stretched credulity. Their question was not whether reassuring language could be written. It was whether governments would accept, in advance, the duty to honour it.

The question of territory remains immediately behind the question of guarantees. European governments backed President Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s refusal to cede land, according to a [separate account of the Berlin meeting](https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/ukraines-allies-hold-line-berlin-102126110.html), even as Kushner pressed for compromise. A guarantee describes the defence of a state; it does not, by itself, settle where that state’s borders will lie.

There is an old convenience in diplomatic language: a government can be described as comfortable long before its signature appears. The Berlin proposal therefore leaves two tests. Moscow must accept the arrangement in a form others can verify. Washington and its European partners must then persuade Ukraine that their signatures carry men, weapons and political will behind them. Until those questions are answered, “comfortable” remains a report about the negotiating room rather than a security guarantee.
