On Sept. 18, government lawyers acknowledged in federal court in Maine that an entry a Homeland Security agent made about Carlyn Williams in ICE’s Palantir-built case system led to her being pulled aside at the Canadian border in March, Biometric Update reported. Ms. Williams had not watched anything. Her spouse, Polyxenia Pantos, had pulled over in Ms. Williams’s car on Jan. 20 to photograph an immigration arrest in Portland.
Court papers released in redacted form on Oct. 2 in Hilton v. Mullin, a proposed class action, show how a sidewalk photograph became a federal file. An agent with Homeland Security Investigations, identified only as J.C., ran the car’s plate through Accurint, a LexisNexis law-enforcement database, and got back Ms. Williams’s address, phone numbers and the names of the people she lives with. He then opened records on both women in Investigative Case Management, or ICM, the system Palantir Technologies built for ICE. The plaintiffs say he logged at least six observers this way. The government’s own count is eight. Wired first reported the filings.
Where ICM sends its records is the reason the case matters. Under a design ICE described in a 2016 privacy assessment, subject records created in ICM are published to TECS, the Customs and Border Protection system officers use to screen travelers. The federal appeals court covering Maine has held since 2011 that the First Amendment protects filming officers in public. Whether that amendment or the Privacy Act of 1974 stops agents from keeping files on the people who film is a much less settled question, and the Maine case puts it squarely before a judge.
The Department of Homeland Security called the claim “meritless” and said the suit “is based on the lie that there is a database of ‘domestic terrorists’ run by DHS.” Its motion to dismiss says J.C. acted against department policy, created records on people he believed posed a safety threat and did not nominate anyone to the terrorist watchlist. Gizmodo described the case as a state-court action. The docket, No. 2:26-cv-00092, is in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine.
From a sidewalk to a file
The Trump administration opened Operation Catch of the Day in Maine on Jan. 20. The department said it arrested 206 people from Jan. 20 to 24. Data later released by the Deportation Data Project showed 192 arrests from Jan. 20 to 28, and only 12 of those people had criminal convictions, The Portland Press Herald reported.
Ms. Pantos was driving to work on the operation’s first day when she passed agents at the roadside and stopped, according to Mother Jones. She took photographs, saw an agent photograph another observer’s license plate and left after about five minutes, with no one detained. That afternoon Ms. Williams got a call from an undisclosed number. The caller said he was with the Department of Homeland Security and asked whether anyone else drove her car. According to Ms. Williams, he said she should encourage her spouse not to “do anything like that in the future,” because such people “might get added to a domestic terrorism watchlist.”
In a deposition, J.C. denied mentioning a watchlist but said he had warned Ms. Williams that she could be arrested if the observing continued, according to the filing. The record he opened described her car as one used to “interrupt ICE arrests” and linked her driver’s license photo to an “aggressive woman” in an enforcement action, International Business Times UK reported. Ms. Williams was not the person on the sidewalk.
On March 16 the couple drove home from an anniversary trip to Canada. At the checkpoint, an officer called the stop routine, took their phones, passports and car keys, and asked about Ms. Williams’s car, which neither had mentioned. “That, I think, is when we realized something was wrong,” Ms. Pantos told Mother Jones. The two are foster parents and feared the episode could affect that status. Ms. Pantos stopped observing ICE altogether, and said this to the magazine about the January stop:
I feel terrible that I put our foster child and my spouse in danger, people that I love so much.
The other records in the filings follow the same pattern. J.C. filmed two people in a Home Depot parking lot, tagged them in ICM as “Threat to Law Enforcement, Professional Protestor” and sent their photographs to a Customs and Border Protection officer, who ran facial-recognition searches through an app called Mobile Query, the plaintiffs say. The suit also alleges that agents drove past observers’ homes. Ms. Williams now faces mandatory secondary screening at international crossings through at least January 2027, International Business Times UK reported.
What ICM holds and shares
ICE switched on ICM for its investigators on June 26, 2016, replacing the case functions of the old Treasury Enforcement Communications System, the legacy TECS. By the next day it had 11,000 users in Homeland Security Investigations, according to department statements cited in a 2017 Electronic Privacy Information Center records request. ICE paid Palantir more than $41 million under the 2014 contract to build it.
The department’s privacy impact assessment, dated June 16, 2016, describes an “Interface Hub” that continually publishes ICE subject records into CBP’s TECS platform, where they “serve as ‘lookout records’” for screening travelers, according to Biometric Update’s reading of the document. An August 2021 update changed the sharing arrangement with CBP but did not end it. A federal contract notice for the system lists “Subject Management” for people, businesses and vehicles, including sharing subject information with CBP “for lookout and seizure tracking.” Not every ICM record becomes a formal lookout, and the public record does not show which mechanism flagged Ms. Williams.
The front end of the pipeline is commercial. ICE has bought Accurint access since February 2021 under a contract worth about $24.51 million, with up to 11,200 authorized users, Biometric Update reported. The agency ran more than 1.2 million person searches from March to September 2021 alone. LexisNexis says its identifier draws on “more than 82 billion public and proprietary records from over 10,000 sources,” and it warns users that the data may contain errors and should be checked independently.
The money has grown with the mission. ICE renewed Palantir’s ICM support in September 2022 with a five-year, $95.5 million contract, FedScoop reported. In April 2025 it added nearly $30 million for a prototype called ImmigrationOS. Wired put Palantir’s ICM-related awards since 2022 at nearly $126 million. In June, ICE gave the company a $45.85 million order to rebuild the system and move its data into an “Enterprise Lakehouse” linked to CBP, the F.B.I.’s criminal-records division and the department’s biometrics office.
Palantir did not respond to Wired’s requests for comment. Its standing position is that the data belongs to the agencies. “Our customers control their own data and manage access to that data,” the company said in a statement to NPR in July about a separate dispute over Medicaid records. It made the broader case in June 2025, answering a letter from Democratic lawmakers:
Betty Gedlu and Cindy Cohn of the Electronic Frontier Foundation answered that line in an April blog post. “A narrow denial about a single database does not answer the broader question,” they wrote, arguing that what matters is what Palantir’s tools let ICE agents do.
On Hacker News, a reader replying to a suggestion that a future Justice Department could buy Palantir’s own records of ICE activity made the company’s point in technical terms.
FYI Palantir doesn’t store anything themselves. These are on-prem or private cloud deployments on top of actual data stores.
That matches how Palantir describes its business, and the Maine records are ICE’s, not the company’s. It is a narrower point than it sounds, though. The feature that carried Ms. Williams’s entry toward the border, sharing subject records with CBP for lookouts, is written into the specifications ICE set and Palantir built, and the new contract keeps it.
What officials said
Five days before the Maine surge, Tom Homan, the White House border czar, told Laura Ingraham on Fox News what he wanted. “One thing I’m pushing for right now, we’re going to create a database,” he said. “Those people that are interfering, we’re going to make them famous and put their face on TV.” In the same interview he said people who “want to follow ICE and film ICE” had the right to protest.
On Jan. 23 an agent in South Portland scanned the face of Colleen Fagan, a 31-year-old social worker who was filming him, and appeared to record her license plate. When she asked why, he answered: “’Cause we have a nice little database. And now you’re considered a domestic terrorist.” The clip spread on X the same day, including in this post by Nathan Bernard, a freelance reporter in Maine. Mother Jones put its views at more than 7 million.
ICE agent in Portland, Maine tells legal observer she is a domestic terrorist for peacefully recording him, adds her to “nice little database”
Tricia McLaughlin, then the department’s assistant secretary for public affairs, replied that “There is NO database of ‘domestic terrorists’ run by DHS.” At a February congressional hearing, Todd Lyons, then the acting ICE director, said, “There is no database for protesters.” Ms. Fagan and Elinor Hilton, 23, who said an agent at a South Portland Home Depot told her on Jan. 21 that she was going on a watch list, sued on Feb. 23.
At a hearing on March 16, Stephen Tagert, an assistant U.S. attorney, told Judge John A. Woodcock Jr., “We don’t think what happened here was proper.” Two ICE officials said in declarations that neither Ms. Hilton nor Ms. Fagan had been added to any database, The Press Herald reported, though photographs officers took of them still existed. The government’s defense rested on a 2019 department memo barring agents from targeting people for their First Amendment activity. That memo had been reissued to Boston-area officers on March 10, after the suit was filed, and was marked “Archived” on the department’s website until a reporter asked about it, Mother Jones reported.
Judge Woodcock asked where the biometric information had gone if it was not in a database. Mr. Tagert’s answer was recorded by Time:
It may be on a phone somewhere. I don’t have the answer to that.
A week later the judge denied an emergency order, calling the request “too broad” and “likely unenforceable under the law,” and finding no evidence yet of a protester database, The Press Herald reported. He wrote that the suit “raises serious constitutional issues that are better aired and resolved on a nonemergency basis.” Ms. Pantos and Ms. Williams joined the case in an amended complaint on April 27.

Mr. Lyons put the agency’s position in writing in an April 21 letter to Representative Maxwell Frost, first reported by NPR. ICE “does not maintain any kind of database of U.S. citizens protesting ICE activities,” he wrote. But it collects “essential biographic and biometric information and situational details” on people “reasonably believed to be involved in, or directly supporting, potential violations of federal law,” and “to address officer safety and facility security concerns.” For people never arrested, that information “is treated as an official government record.” Scarlet Kim, an A.C.L.U. lawyer, told NPR that the department’s definition of potential violations “includes activities that are squarely protected by the First Amendment.”
Set against the filings, the denials hold up only on their own narrow terms. No public record shows a database labeled “domestic terrorists,” and the government says no plaintiff was nominated to the terrorist watchlist. ICM is a general case system, not a protester list. But the Lyons letter describes almost exactly what J.C. did: officer-safety collection on people never arrested, kept as official records in a system that talks to the border. The March declarations covered only Ms. Hilton and Ms. Fagan, and the public filings do not make clear whether either is among the eight.
On Hacker News, a reader saw the same gap in the department’s statement.
Wait, wouldn’t you want/ expect DHS to maintain a database of domestic terrorists? That wasn’t even the question!
Congress has pressed the point. When Senator Ed Markey asked in February whether ICE kept a protester database, ICE answered on May 22 by describing the F.B.I.-run terrorist watchlist, which he had not asked about. “ICE’s shifting and carefully worded responses prevent Congress and the public from determining” the scope of its surveillance, Mr. Markey and Mr. Frost wrote on July 1, according to Mother Jones.
The 1970s and after
The legal question is older than ICE. After the riots of 1967 and 1968, Army intelligence built a system that gathered information on lawful civilian political activity. Senate hearings exposed it, the Army destroyed its blacklist and a computer data bank at Fort Holabird, and activists sued anyway. In Laird v. Tatum, decided 5 to 4 in 1972, the Supreme Court held that a “subjective ‘chill’” from the mere existence of surveillance was no substitute for “a claim of specific present objective harm or a threat of specific future harm.”
Congress answered two years later. A clause in the Privacy Act, Section 552a(e)(7), bars agencies from keeping any record “describing how any individual exercises rights guaranteed by the First Amendment” unless a statute or the person allows it, or the record is “pertinent to and within the scope of an authorized law enforcement activity.” Agencies can’t exempt a system from that clause. The exception is the fight. In Garris v. F.B.I. in 2019, the Ninth Circuit ordered the bureau to expunge a 2004 memo about an antiwar website, holding that “unless a record is pertinent to an ongoing authorized law enforcement activity, an agency may not maintain it.” Other circuits read the exception more generously, and the First Circuit, which covers Maine, has not settled the question.
The closest precedent to Maine came out of San Diego. In March 2019, NBC 7 San Diego obtained screenshots of a CBP file on 59 people tied to the migrant caravan, 10 of them described as journalists or media, flagged for secondary inspection at the border. One lawyer’s dossier listed her car and her mother’s name, BuzzFeed News reported. CBP called the work “standard law enforcement practice.” Five photojournalists sued, a federal judge in Brooklyn let their First Amendment claim proceed in 2021, and in January the government settled, agreeing to issue CBP guidance on First Amendment and Privacy Act protections and to take steps so their past reporting would not drive future questioning, the A.C.L.U. said.
The case for the agents
The department’s strongest argument is officer safety. It counted 647 assaults on ICE personnel from Jan. 20, 2025, to Sept. 20, against 37 in the same span of 2021 and 2022, an increase of 1,649 percent, according to a Sept. 24 release. The baseline is small and the count is the department’s own, not independently verified. Officer safety was also the reason Apple gave Congress for pulling an ICE-tracking app.
The law of filming has limits too. Glik v. Cunniffe, the 2011 First Circuit case, protects a citizen’s right to film officers “in the discharge of their duties in a public space,” and Gericke v. Begin in 2014 extended it to traffic stops. But the court said reasonable restrictions can apply and that a right to record is not a right to interfere. The government says J.C. made his records so agents could look people up if they met them again, and it can cite Laird for the rule that a chill alone does not make a case.
Hannah Berkman and Stacy Livingston of Yale Law School’s Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic took the other side in Lawfare in February. Under the Supreme Court’s 2021 ruling in Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta, they wrote, the government must show that compiling the identities of protesters bears “a substantial relation” to an important interest, and Bonta “appears to have cut back” on Laird.
The Constitution almost certainly does not allow federal officials to assemble a database of those who film ICE officers
On the record so far, the Maine plaintiffs are not in the Laird plaintiffs’ position. They point to specific harms: a border stop the government concedes followed from an ICM entry, a phone warning about arrest, and Ms. Pantos’s decision to stop observing. The safety rationale is harder to square with the facts in the filings. Ms. Pantos took photographs and left within about five minutes with no one detained, yet the record on her spouse described a car used to “interrupt ICE arrests.”
The government’s “isolated incident” argument fits the Maine facts better: one agent, eight records. Whether it is policy depends on evidence from elsewhere. Mr. Markey’s February letter quoted an internal memo telling agents sent to Minneapolis to “capture all images, license plates, identifications, and general information on hotels, agitators, protestors, etc.” In Spokane, Wash., records show a police detective working on an HSI task force ran the plates of protesters who, by her own account, “remained peaceful,” Mother Jones reported in July.
On Reddit, a reader asked why any of this was news.
I mean, ICE agents were taking pictures and already bragging the pictures were going into a database. Why is this a shock now?
The boast was public in January. What was not public until the Oct. 2 filings was the government’s own account of where the records went, which system holds them and that one of them reached the border. Until then the department’s answer had been that no such database existed.
The Maine suit leans entirely on the Constitution. Its four counts are First Amendment claims. The Privacy Act route is being tested in San Diego, where the Electronic Privacy Information Center and three observers sued on July 24, alleging a “Protester Surveillance Policy” and records kept in CBP’s Automated Targeting System. All three individual plaintiffs say they lost Global Entry or TSA PreCheck after observing agents. The Privacy Act covers only citizens and lawful permanent residents, a limit restated in the 2019 department memo.
What comes next
The Maine plaintiffs filed a motion for a preliminary injunction under seal in September, and a redacted version became public on Oct. 2. They ask Judge Woodcock to order Ms. Williams’s records archived, bar the department from using the information against them and stop agents in Maine from threatening observers with watchlists or following them home. The government’s motion to dismiss is pending, and no hearing date has been made public. Ms. Pantos and Ms. Williams are not the only Maine residents whose border crossings have drawn attention. An immigration advocate sued last week over a phone seized at Miami’s airport.
The setting has hardened since January. On July 13, ICE agents shot and killed Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero outside his family’s apartment in Biddeford, The Boston Globe reported. The EPIC case is before Judge Anthony J. Battaglia in the Southern District of California.
The system itself is changing under the lawsuit. ICE’s June order requires the existing ICM data to move into Palantir’s new platform, and the documents do not show whether the eight Maine records have been migrated. The contract requires that the data be moved “without exceptions or errors.”

