---
title: "Germany fines teens to fill its army as Canada runs out of money for cadets who show up"
description: "German students strike against a registration letter that threatens a €250 fine, while Canada pauses weekend cadet training over a budget cap"
author: "Nate Ledger"
published: 2026-11-20T06:20:26Z
modified: 2026-11-20T13:16:47Z
url: https://rews.cc/a/germany-fines-teens-to-fill-its-army-as-canada-runs-out-of-m-accc2d
language: en
tags: ["military", "conscription", "budget", "defence", "germany", "us", "europe"]
publisher: "Rews (https://rews.cc)"
---

# Germany fines teens to fill its army as Canada runs out of money for cadets who show up

*German students strike against a registration letter that threatens a €250 fine, while Canada pauses weekend cadet training over a budget cap*

By Nate Ledger · November 20, 2026 · https://rews.cc/a/germany-fines-teens-to-fill-its-army-as-canada-runs-out-of-m-accc2d

## In brief

- German teenagers are receiving Bundeswehr registration forms, and men who don’t respond can be fined €250
- Germany’s Military Service Modernisation Act targets about 260,000 full-time troops and 200,000 reservists by the mid-2030s
- Student groups held rallies against conscription on November 20, with nearly 20,000 signed up across 40 cities
- Germany’s 2027 draft budget raises defence to €109.7bn and cuts the education and family ministry to €15.9bn
- Canada has paused weekend cadet training until March after summer spending and a rise of about 20,000 members hit a budget cap

In the abstract, every military wants young people. In practice that turns out to cover two very different problems, and this week offered a clean example of each. Germany has young people it would like to recruit, and they would rather it didn’t. Canada has young people who keep turning up to its military-run youth programme, and it can’t afford them.

Start with Germany. Last month Phil Werring, an 18-year-old high school student in Muenster, got a letter from the Bundeswehr, [as Gouri Sharma reported for Al Jazeera](https://aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/20/we-dont-want-our-future-decided-by-the-military-young-germans-protest). It was a military registration form. Some of its questions were compulsory: illnesses, weight, height, sports. Others were optional and aimed at anyone who might want to enlist: did he have a driving licence, which languages did he speak. He ignored it. Two weeks later a second letter arrived warning that not responding could cost him €250 ($275). So he scanned the QR code, spent about 15 minutes on the required section and skipped everything else, knowing that leaving the optional part blank might make it more likely he gets called in for a check-up. He found the whole thing “quite scary, and it made me angry.”

The machinery behind the letter is the Military Service Modernisation Act, in force since January 1, 2026. It aims for roughly 260,000 full-time troops plus 200,000 reservists by the mid-2030s. Service itself is still voluntary; Germany suspended conscription in 2011. What is mandatory is the paperwork, for men. By the end of October nearly 600,000 letters had gone out this year: about 286,800 to men and about 271,700 to women and other genders, who don’t have to answer.

![A person with a backpack pulls on a giant cream-colored military uniform with a helmet and red medal against a blue background.](https://rews.cc/img/437f86f5d5c0ed01e17ac9e1be16a7e27ec1ed32.webp)

I think the useful way to see this is as a sales funnel. A volunteer army is a product you have to sell, and the questionnaire is the lead-generation form. The compulsory questions get the state your basic data (with a €250 penalty for refusing, which is not a feature most lead-gen forms have). The optional questions are the upsell. The letters to women are pure marketing, since nobody is obliged to reply. The Ministry of Defence says the funnel is working: the Bundeswehr has beaten its statutory build-up range for 2026, and October headcount was about 6,400 higher than a year before. The catch is in the fine print. If not enough people volunteer, the Bundestag can bring back compulsory service, and the teenagers have noticed.

## The other column of the budget

They are striking. A youth-led alliance called School Strike Against Conscription has thousands of students lined up for rallies on Friday, and Gen Z Regelt (“Gen Z Sorts It”), a loose alliance behind earlier school strikes, says nearly 20,000 people have signed up across 40 cities, including Berlin, Cologne, Frankfurt and Munich. It’s not new. Students walked out on December 5, 2025, before the law had even passed, and again on March 5 and May 8, according to the [European Bureau for Conscientious Objection](https://www.ebco-beoc.org/2026-10-13-germany-school-strikes), which counted around 45,000 students in more than 80 cities and towns at a fourth strike in September. Anadolu Agency [reported more than 100,000 students](https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/german-students-hold-nationwide-rallies-against-welfare-cuts-conscription/4107684) on the streets on November 1, when the young [marched against conscription and cuts](https://rews.cc/a/germany-s-young-march-in-34-cities-against-conscription-cuts-6918e0) together.

![A group of protesters holds blank signs and pushes up a giant military helmet against a blue background.](https://rews.cc/img/f400d2c1a59bb1c73a0b18c921ec3a727bb8f76a.webp)

The cuts are the other half of it. Linus Schneider, 16, goes to a school in Munich, the biggest city in rich Bavaria, where the roofs have leaked for three years and gym class is sometimes cancelled because there are buckets catching water in the sports hall. His head teacher has already disciplined him for protesting, and he plans to go on Friday anyway. “We don’t want our future to be decided by the military or the state,” he said. The 2027 draft budget, due to be agreed later this month, lifts defence spending to €109.7bn from €82.7bn and cuts the Ministry for Education and Family to €15.9bn from €16.6bn. So defence goes up €27bn and education and family go down €0.7bn, which means defence would get almost seven times as much. If your gym is full of buckets, that is a fairly legible set of numbers.

Werring wants to study medicine. “I want to help people, not shoot or harm anyone,” he said. Sebastian Koos, a sociologist at the University of Konstanz, called the youth protests spreading across Europe an “important spark”. He said conscription is what makes the German case unusual, and that what links them all is hopelessness, about inequality, the far right, the cost of living and the climate.

## Meanwhile, too many volunteers

Now Canada, which has the reverse problem. Leaked emails obtained by several outlets, [including CBC News](https://cbc.ca/news/politics/cadets-defence-training-budget-9.7428707), show that weekend training and competitions for cadets are halted until the fiscal year ends in March. The compulsory weekly parade nights carry on, at least for now. On Thursday Vice-Admiral Angus Topshee, the vice chief of the defence staff, explained why to the House of Commons public accounts committee. Cadet membership has grown by roughly 20,000 over the last few years, and funding has risen to $265 million a year. But:

![Uniformed people stand in a line facing an enormous open purse.](https://rews.cc/img/51b5666aec4c1470a9c46e1f4b3676267b72d6ad.webp)

> Unfortunately, a lot of the cadet funding is front-loaded. It happens during the summer months. And so they spent a large part of that expanded budget on summer training. And we didn’t factor in the sizable increase in the number of cadets participating in the program.

So: an annual budget with a hard cap, a big chunk of it spent on summer camps, more kids than anyone planned for, and by November the money is nearly gone. “They are now on track to exceed that and they are living within their means, as all of us within the Department of Defence are,” Topshee said. “We are required to live within the budget we’ve been given and they spent theirs a little bit faster than they were intended to.” Translation: the forecast was wrong, so the kids lose their weekends. Christiane Fox, the deputy minister of defence, told the same committee that she supports bringing the paused training back, calling cadets “an essential program” for young Canadians to build “confidence, leadership, skill sets that we need.” The department says both the cadet and junior ranger programmes are under review and that it is too early to know “the full extent of any changes.”

What makes this awkward is that Canada is not short of defence money in general. Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government has sharply increased military spending and has largely spared the department from its expenditure review. The parliamentary budget watchdog says direct military spending could top $163 billion by 2035. But the department has been told to put its new billions into priorities like new equipment, and it still has to deliver cuts to operations and maintenance from a Trudeau-era budget: $459 million in savings this year. For scale, the entire cadet programme costs about 58% of that.

Germany is threatening teenagers with a €250 fine to get them to say how tall they are. Canada has about 20,000 more teenagers than it planned for volunteering to spend their weekends in uniform, and is currently telling them to stay home.

## Sources

- [‘We don’t want our future decided by the military’: Young Germans protest](https://aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/20/we-dont-want-our-future-decided-by-the-military-young-germans-protest) — aljazeera.com
- [Military defends suspending cadet training, citing budget pressure](https://cbc.ca/news/politics/cadets-defence-training-budget-9.7428707) — cbc.ca
