A 15-year-old student lost a hand on Monday in Lens, in northern France, during a protest outside his school. CBS News, drawing on AFP, reported that a police union source told the news agency the boy appeared to have picked up a sting-ball grenade fired by riot police, and that it exploded in his hand. The public prosecutor in Béthune, Etienne Thieffry, was more careful. “I am not in a position to say formally whether the student picked up the grenade or whether it was thrown at him,” he said, according to franceinfo, which reported that the police inspectorate, the IGPN, has opened an investigation. The boy, in his first year at the Auguste-Béhal vocational lycée, was taken to hospital in Lille. His life is not in danger. The education minister, Edouard Geffray, called it “humanly dramatic”.
The French Human Rights League accused the security forces on Monday of using disproportionate methods against protesters, many of them minors. “We can see that in the instructions given to the police, there is no directive to show restraint, even though they are dealing with children,” said its president, Nathalie Tehio.
The protests themselves are about school. According to AFP, the movement started on Sept. 17 at a high school in the Paris suburb of Créteil, in support of teachers striking over a lack of staff and resources. Al Jazeera’s Shola Lawal dates the first class boycotts to Sept. 21, in deprived areas of Paris. Either way, it has gone national. Rory Carroll in The Guardian lists what the students say is wrong: classes of up to 40 in crumbling buildings, poor teacher pay, staff absences, an opaque online system for university applications, classrooms that bake during heatwaves, and leaks, cockroaches and collapsed ceilings. Bilal Narjissi, a 17-year-old protester, told CBS his school had rats. One cardboard sign outside the Turgot high school in Paris read: “We’re missing our lessons to give you one.”
The numbers have got large quickly. On Sunday Geffray said lessons would be “totally or partly suspended” at 400 to 500 high schools on Monday because security conditions “have not been fulfilled”, as the South China Morning Post reported. He said 24 schools had been “burned or ransacked” and 78 education staff wounded, “something we have never seen before.” On Monday morning the ministry put the count at more than 400 of France’s 3,700 lycées. Valérie Pécresse, the right-wing president of the Ile-de-France region, said more than a third of its 468 lycées would close. More than 5,000 people had been arrested by then, 85% of them minors, and internal investigations had been opened into at least three cases of alleged police brutality. On Tuesday, the biggest day yet, the main pupils’ union said about 1,800 lycées were affected, and Reuters reported that the interior ministry now counts 6,100 arrests. Police fired tear gas at blockades, according to Reuters via Al Jazeera, while marchers in Marseille, Nantes and Lyon carried signs reading “they don’t really care about us” and “survive or study.”
Whose budget is the ceiling?
The government’s answer has two halves, and they point in rather different directions. The first half is about the grievances. On Sunday Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu told local authorities to make filling long-term teacher absences and vacant posts the priority, and Europe 1 reported that his roadmap wants a first progress report on that by Oct. 16. He also called a meeting with regional presidents for Tuesday about the buildings.
Here is where the structure matters. In France the state employs lycée teachers, but the regional councils are responsible for lycée buildings. So “my teacher is never here” is a national problem, while “my ceiling fell in” is a regional one, and each can tell the students the other one is at fault. Lecornu’s letter anticipates this and says neither the state nor the regions should shift the blame onto each other. The president of Bourgogne-Franche-Comté replied on franceinfo that his region had lost €106 million in state funding over two years, and that “the State can’t tell us ‘do your job’ while it dips into our finances.” He also said he hadn’t been invited. Neither, he said, had any other regional president.
The second half is about who pays for the damage. The government is pushing a bill to make people who damage public property pay for repairs themselves. Lecornu has said it could let compensation be recovered from family allowances and housing benefits, with a minimum income threshold preserved. The government spokeswoman, Maud Bregeon, put it this way: “When you have 14-, 15-, 16-year-olds who, at 9 a.m., are burning bus shelters or — perhaps even more seriously — the high school where they study, that raises the question of parental responsibility.” Sophie Binet, who heads the CGT union, called it a “populist announcement” that would “end up targeting the most vulnerable families.”
Take the mechanics seriously for a moment. The students’ complaint is that public money for their schools has dried up. The proposed fix for the damage is to recover repair costs from payments the state makes to families, and housing benefit mostly goes to families without much money. So the state would be paying for its schools out of its own welfare spending. You could describe that as accountability. You could also describe it as moving money from one public budget to another, with poorer families’ benefits in between.
The other part of the official message is order. Bregeon said the priority was to “restore order”. Geffray said “activists – particularly from the far-left” had “infiltrated the high school student movement, hijacked it from the students themselves and engaged in extreme violence.” The violence has been real. A 16-year-old was detained over an attack in La Ciotat on Friday in which a 59-year-old teacher was struck and doused with petrol. Two Bulgarian youths aged 15 and 17 are under investigation after a policeman was beaten in Belfort. The interior minister, Laurent Nuñez, says the police “are not cracking down on young people” but “protecting” students who want to “peacefully voice their demands”. Amnesty France’s president, Anne Savinel-Barras, said young people must be able to protest “without fear of being hit by tear gas grenades or batons, or being arbitrarily taken into police custody.” Student leader Daphnee Die told CBS the anger was “understandable, but it’s getting really dangerous.”
All this is happening months before next year’s election to choose President Emmanuel Macron’s successor, and while unions are pressing Lecornu over budget cuts and a wealth tax. According to Europe 1, the government is aiming for students to start drifting back to class from Wednesday. Ministers also have until the end of October to propose fixes to the university-application system. The students had already set a deadline of their own. It was Tuesday.

