Michael Freeman, editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, has concluded that Jeffrey Epstein was strangled, most likely from behind, while awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges in 2019. Freeman reached that conclusion after a years-long examination of autopsy records and photographs, Al Jazeera reported.

His specific anatomical claim concerns the marks left by the material around Epstein’s neck. “The ligature marks are most consistent with homicidal strangulation from behind, most likely using a narrow knotted fabric ligature,” Freeman said in a presentation to Middle Temple, a London legal society, according to CNN. CNN also reports that the New York City medical examiner continues to stand by the suicide determination.

Freeman told CBS News that his review covered the autopsy records, photographs and a biomedical reconstruction he produced. “The injuries that were documented by the medical examiner were not consistent with the suicidal hanging,” he said. He argued that injuries potentially associated with a physical struggle or assault had been overlooked rather than adequately explained.

A magnifying glass enlarges a black line splitting into black and red paths on textured paper.

The BBC reports that Freeman, a professor, reviewed the New York City medical examiner’s file before reaching his conclusion. That access distinguishes his work from speculation based only on public accounts of Epstein’s detention. It does not make his interpretation the official finding: review of the same file can produce disagreement over what a pattern of injuries implies about the mechanism of death.

An expert challenge, not a changed death classification

The dispute centres on manner of death—the classification separating suicide from homicide—rather than a new autopsy. Freeman infers homicidal strangulation from the documented injuries and his reconstruction. The medical examiner maintains suicide. The New York Times, which described Freeman as a forensic scientist who studies homicides and had rare access to the file, also notes that previous investigations found most evidence pointed toward suicide rather than homicide.

Those positions should not be collapsed into a claim that homicide has been established. Freeman’s analysis supplies a contrary expert interpretation of wounds and ligature marks; it does not itself revise the medical examiner’s ruling or settle responsibility. A further official review would have to address each injury, test the proposed rear-strangulation mechanism against the suicide explanation and determine whether the existing classification should change. Whether any medical or legal authority undertakes that review remains unresolved.