A federal judge in Oklahoma ruled on Thursday that a sheriff’s deputy violated a woman’s Fourth Amendment rights when he ran her license plate through Flock Safety’s nationwide camera network without a warrant, then used her travel history as part of the justification to search her car.
Judge Sara Hill ordered every piece of evidence from the stop thrown out, including 91 pounds of methamphetamine found in the woman’s Mazda SUV, writing that it “must be suppressed as the fruit of a poisonous tree.” The ruling is one of the first times a federal judge has held that a search of the Flock system is unconstitutional. It sets no binding precedent, and other cases testing the practice are pending around the country.
The stop began in May, when Freddie Alaniz, a Tulsa County deputy sheriff parked along a highway, watched the SUV pass with California plates. “Alaniz then pulled his vehicle on the highway to follow the Mazda for no apparent reason other than the fact that it had a California license plate,” Judge Hill wrote. He ran the plate through Flock, pulled the driver, Melisa Kyle, over ostensibly for changing lanes without signaling, and made her recount the previous several days while he checked her answers against the system. The query returned more than 50 records of Ms. Kyle’s whereabouts across the country over an entire month. Deputy Alaniz told her the short stay in California made him suspect drug trafficking, then searched the car.
“This is a type of indiscriminate mass surveillance,” the judge wrote of the Flock network. “It is not targeted on a single individual. It is a tool that collects information about all vehicles that pass by any network-connected camera at all times, and it serves up the information to law enforcement on demand.” Tracking drivers in public becomes constitutionally problematic, she wrote, when the police can “indiscriminately and passively catalog your whereabouts over an extended period of time and then use that information for any purpose whenever convenient.”
Earlier decisions upholding warrantless plate searches leaned on a 1983 Supreme Court case, United States v. Knotts, involving one tracking device in a chemical container. That court faced “much less sophisticated technology,” Judge Hill wrote; Flock’s network is quickly “approaching dragnet-type law enforcement practice.” The factors the government cited for suspicion, she added, “are the same type of circumstances that everyday Americans encounter on long road trips for many legitimate reasons.”
More than 100,000 warrantless searches of the Flock system are run each month, according to audit logs viewed by 404 Media. The ruling follows the Supreme Court’s decision in Chatrie v. United States, which held that police access to a person’s digital data, including cellphone location records, is a search, according to 404 Media.
Days earlier, a jury in a suit brought by the Institute for Justice found that a U.S. Border Patrol traffic-stop program built on plate scans was unconstitutional. “The way courts have resolved these cases previously has been way too myopic,” Michael Soyfer, a lawyer at the institute, told 404 Media, saying judges have ignored “the sweeping modes of surveillance that allow police to reconstruct the movements of anyone in the country.”
Flock, which was not a party to the case, said in a statement that the ruling “goes against the overwhelming weight of authority in similar cases across the country” and that “we expect it will be appealed and ultimately overturned.” In July, the company’s chief executive, Garrett Langley, had called the constitutional question “pretty cut and dry” in an interview with The Drive, saying the courts “have deemed this is not a warrantless search.”
The decision arrives as license plate readers turn into an election issue. Nearly 80 percent of American police departments use them, more than 120,000 cameras operate nationwide, and every department serving a population over one million has them, according to Bureau of Justice Statistics figures. But in the past year alone, more than 50 municipalities have cut ties with Flock and other vendors, according to the advocacy group DeFlock.
On Sept. 23, a Senate committee led by Josh Hawley, Republican of Missouri, and Dick Durbin, Democrat of Illinois, held a hearing on the cameras; Flock, Axon, Motorola and Verkada were invited, and none came. Mr. Hawley then announced the Stop Flock Act, which would bar local governments from sharing vehicle data with private third parties and limit retention to 10 days in most cases. At least four bills restricting the readers were introduced in September alone, and on Friday, Senators Bernie Sanders and Jeff Merkley and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez announced the Block Flock Act, which would bar federal agencies from using such systems.
On the campaign trail, Angie Nixon, the Democratic Senate nominee in Florida, has called for warrants before plate data is searched and mandatory deletion periods, while Gov. Ron DeSantis, a Republican, banned the cameras on state highways in early September. In Michigan’s Senate race, Abdul El-Sayed, a Democrat, and his Republican opponent, Mike Rogers, are each attacking the technology; Mr. Rogers’s campaign said he “vehemently opposes unchecked use of Flock cameras to track law-abiding citizens.” Donald Trump is a rare dissenter, having said of the cameras, “I like them.”
The cameras also misidentify vehicles: Lindsey Isaacs, a Florida woman, spent 13 days in jail on triple-homicide charges after a Flock camera wrongly flagged her Dodge Durango in a fatal hit-and-run. A September survey of more than 1,400 adults by the National Policing Institute found 80 percent approved of using the readers to find missing children or investigate violent crimes, while about three-quarters opposed their use for immigration enforcement or routine traffic and parking enforcement.
Under the pressure, Mr. Langley has apologized to women stalked by officers using his system and called for a “compromise” between privacy and safety; Flock has offered employees voluntary buyouts to shrink its work force, TechCrunch reported. Judge Hill’s order applies only to Ms. Kyle’s case.

