California counties had until Monday to start mailing ballots for a Nov. 3 vote on Proposition 40, a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of the state’s billionaires. Six of the best-known people it was written to reach left the state before its Jan. 1 residency cutoff, and by Fortune’s count they took about $27 billion in potential revenue with them.
That is roughly a quarter of the $100 billion the measure’s authors project. It is also the least disputed number in the fight. Economists on both sides largely agree on who left before New Year’s Day and roughly what those fortunes were worth. They split over what happens next: whether billionaires who stayed can still get out by moving now, how much income tax the state loses when they go and whether a residency date set 10 months before the vote holds up in court.
Read side by side, the estimates show that the early departures cost the tax $27 billion to $29 billion. That is a real loss, not a fatal one. The deeper cuts in the critics’ forecasts, down to about $30 billion in a Stanford paper dated Sept. 22, come mostly from two other bets: that judges will strike or narrow the Jan. 1 rule, and that the billionaires who stayed will find ways to shrink their bills. Those two bets will decide whether California collects anything, along with two rival measures on the same ballot that could void the tax even if a majority votes for it.
Who left, and when
The proposal surfaced in October 2025, when Bloomberg reported that a health care workers’ union, SEIU United Healthcare Workers West, was backing it. Its drafters were the tax law professors Brian Galle of the University of California, Berkeley, David Gamage of the University of Missouri and Darien Shanske of the University of California, Davis, along with the Berkeley economist Emmanuel Saez. Anyone who lived in California on Jan. 1, 2026, would owe 5% of worldwide net worth as valued at the end of this year. Real estate, pensions and retirement accounts are generally excluded, according to the Legislative Analyst’s Office. About 90% of the money would go to health care, mainly Medi-Cal, LAist reported.
The moves began before the measure had a single signature. Late in 2025, an entity linked to the Google co-founder Sergey Brin terminated or moved 15 California limited liability companies, seven of which became Nevada entities. More than 45 California L.L.C.s tied to his co-founder Larry Page filed to go inactive or relocate in December, and a trust linked to Mr. Page bought a $71.9 million house in Miami’s Coconut Grove in early January, according to The San Francisco Standard’s tracker, which drew on reporting by The New York Times.
Fortune counted 214 billionaires in the state in March and six who had left in time. Mr. Page, Mr. Brin and the investor Peter Thiel went to Miami. The auto lender Don Hankey went to Las Vegas, and Travis Kalanick, the former Uber chief executive, went to Texas. Steven Spielberg became a New York resident on New Year’s Day, and his representative said the move had long been planned. Mr. Page would have owed about $13 billion and Mr. Brin about $12 billion. Mr. Thiel, Mr. Kalanick and Mr. Hankey together would have owed $1.775 billion.
Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat who opposes the tax, pointed to the Google founders in January. “This is my fear. It’s just what I warned against,” he told Politico. “It’s happening.”
Other cases are murkier. In February, Mark Zuckerberg and his wife, Priscilla Chan, were reported to be buying a waterfront house on Miami’s Indian Creek island at a price estimated at $150 million to $200 million, Fox Business reported, citing The Wall Street Journal. It is not clear whether he has changed his legal residence. Fortune reported that he left after Jan. 1. A paper by Mr. Saez and two colleagues read the press reports as showing he remains a California resident. Both camps now leave Larry Ellison out of the base, though they differ on why. The authors say he has very likely lived in Florida since March 2023, and the Hoover Institution team says he moved to Hawaii in 2020.
Some stayed and said so. Jensen Huang, the Nvidia chief executive, who faces a bill estimated at about $7.75 billion, told Bloomberg Television on Jan. 6 that his company works in Silicon Valley for the talent. “I’m perfectly fine with it,” he said.
Two sets of numbers
The authors’ $100 billion figure comes from simple arithmetic. They took about $2.2 trillion in California billionaire wealth from the Forbes list, applied the 5% rate and cut the result by 10% to cover avoidance, evasion and moves. Jeff Hoopes, research director of the University of North Carolina’s Tax Center, set out the method in a March comparison of the two main estimates. He wrote that the 10% allowance came “without justification” and said he expected Californians to respond more than Europeans have, since escaping requires only a move to another state.
The authors have revised the inputs but kept the total. Their July report dropped Mr. Ellison, worth about $170 billion. It added 24 California billionaires who are not U.S. citizens, worth about $150 billion, whom earlier versions had missed, and it said billionaire wealth rose 12% in the first half of 2026. The estimate still came to about $100 billion.
Joshua Rauh, a Stanford finance professor and senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, built his base one billionaire at a time. His team’s March 4 paper found that the departures had removed $536 billion, nearly 30% of the base, and put collections at about $40 billion over five years. A revised version with Benjamin Jaros, dated Sept. 22 and written for a National Bureau of Economic Research volume, lowered the estimate to about $30 billion, in a range of $28 billion to $36 billion. In that paper, observed departures cut projected revenue by $28.85 billion, to $72.06 billion. The rest of the drop comes from a discount for the chance the tax loses in court and from avoidance estimates drawn from research on wealth taxes.
The bigger argument is about what the state loses later. Mr. Rauh and Mr. Jaros estimate that California’s billionaires pay $3.3 billion to $5.8 billion a year in state income tax. In their model, the permanent loss of that stream from those who leave outweighs the one-time collection. They put the net cost at $38.9 billion in the September paper, up from $24.7 billion in March, and 85% of their 100,000 simulations came out negative.
Mr. Saez and Gabriel Zucman, an economist at Berkeley and the Paris School of Economics, answered with their own data. In a working paper with Jasper Boll released in May, they estimated that California billionaires pay about 0.2% of their wealth a year in state income tax, about $3.2 billion, or 2.4% of the state’s income tax revenue from 2023 to 2025. The paper discloses that Mr. Saez gave unpaid advice on the measure’s design. In a New York Times guest essay on May 26, the two argued that even if every billionaire left, the lost income tax would take 25 years to exceed what the tax would raise. Mr. Zucman made the same case on X.
California’s billionaires currently pay such a low tax rate that even if ALL of them left the state, guess what would happen?
It would take 25 years for the loss of their income tax payments to surpass the amount collected with the 5% one-off wealth tax.
Mr. Rauh and Mr. Jaros sent The Times a letter in reply. They said it went unpublished, so they posted it on Mr. Rauh’s newsletter on June 8. They wrote that the lost income taxes grow and never end, and that the two departures that mattered most had already happened.
Even if only those two departed, the ceiling on collections drops by 30%.
The Legislative Analyst’s Office, the Legislature’s nonpartisan fiscal adviser, did not pick a number. It said the state “probably would collect tens of billions of dollars” and that billionaires’ responses, including leaving, “probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year.” The two camps put billionaires’ annual state income tax at $3.2 billion to $5.8 billion, so that ceiling holds only if most of them stay. The office also expects collection costs of tens of millions of dollars a year for several years.
The Jan. 1 date
The Jan. 1 cutoff is where most of the money is decided. Residency was fixed on New Year’s Day and the vote comes on Nov. 3, so under the measure’s text a billionaire who lived in California on Jan. 1 owes the tax wherever he lives when it passes. Mr. Zucman put it plainly in a Berkeley interview published Sept. 30: “it is too late to move.”
A completed move is also harder to prove than a house purchase. The Franchise Tax Board, which would collect the tax, already audits wealthy people who say they have left. It weighs where they keep their homes and children, their doctors, clubs, driver’s licenses and voter registrations, under a precedent known as Bragg v. State Board of Equalization, Bloomberg Tax reported on Sept. 21. Carl Joseph, a former senior attorney at the board, told Bloomberg Tax about a taxpayer who claimed to have moved, “but he didn’t take the damned dog.”
Once you’re domiciled in a state, you are presumed to stay there unless you show you formed an intention to move.
Some billionaires are moving anyway. David Lesperance, a tax and immigration lawyer, told Bloomberg Tax that others have moved since Jan. 1 or plan to, betting that the retroactive provisions will be struck down. Jon Feldhammer, a San Francisco tax lawyer, told CalMatters that “a third to half” of his clients have left the state. He said the law may well be unconstitutionally retroactive, but that a client has to leave to benefit from that argument.
Their legal theory comes from people like Jared Walczak, a senior fellow at the Tax Foundation, a Washington research group that favors low, broad taxes. He argues that two Supreme Court decisions from the 1920s, Blodgett v. Holden and Untermyer v. Anderson, struck down the retroactive application of newly created taxes, and that Untermyer held that advance warning does not cure the problem. Because backers say even a late-2025 exit may not work, he wrote, the reach-back stretches into 2025.
So long as the wealth tax initiative appears electorally viable, billionaires will be incentivized to move to avoid it.
The drafters cite Brushaber v. Union Pacific, the 1916 ruling that upheld a federal income tax reaching back to the start of 1913, and United States v. Carlton, a 1994 decision allowing some retroactive tax changes. Mr. Walczak calls Brushaber distinguishable. Mr. Feldhammer expects both questions in court, along with years of suits over how private companies were valued.
What Europe showed
In 1990, 12 countries in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development taxed individuals’ net wealth. By 2017 four did: France, Norway, Spain and Switzerland, according to a 2018 OECD study. It said concerns about efficiency and administrative cost, set against limited revenue, drove the repeals. France replaced its tax with a levy on real estate wealth in 2018.
France is the case opponents cite most. In a July 5 Times essay, Mr. Rauh and Mr. Jaros wrote that an estimated 200 billion euros left France over two decades. The French government’s own count is smaller in scale. An average of 750 households a year left from 2003 to 2016, about two in every 1,000 wealth-tax payers, taking roughly 3 billion euros a year in taxable wealth, or 0.4% of the total declared, according to a 2019 evaluation by France Stratégie, a government advisory body. The Hoover Institution promoted the essay on X.
France abolished its wealth tax in 2018 after an exodus of capital. Hoover fellows @JoshRauh and Benjamin Jaros argue California’s proposed version would fare no better, raising far less than promised and pushing billionaires out. Read more in @NYTopinion:
Norway is the more recent example. After it raised taxes on wealth and dividends in 2022, 82 wealthy Norwegians worth about 46 billion kroner left in 2022 and 2023, more than in the previous 13 years combined, Fortune reported, citing Finance Ministry data. Most went to Switzerland. Wealth tax revenue still rose, to an estimated 34 billion kroner in 2025 from 27 billion in 2022, Canadian Affairs reported, in part because some 720,000 Norwegians pay it. California’s tax falls on about 200 people.
Spain is the closest parallel to a state line. After 2011, Madrid was the only Spanish region without a wealth tax. Five years later, its population of wealthy residents had grown 10% relative to other regions, according to a study by David Agrawal, Dirk Foremny and Clara Martínez-Toledano in American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. The published version found that the income tax lost to those moves was six times the wealth tax lost, which supports Mr. Rauh’s emphasis on income tax.
The best American evidence cuts both ways. Enrico Moretti of Berkeley and Daniel Wilson of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco studied the Forbes 400 from 1981 to 2017. After a 2001 federal change made state estate taxes bite, the number of those billionaires living in estate-tax states fell 35% relative to other states. For the average state, though, the estate tax still raised 31% more than it cost in lost income tax.
Mr. Moretti has taken a side. He told The San Francisco Chronicle that Mr. Saez’s estimate was “way overly optimistic” and that billionaires facing a tax like this “will leave in droves.” Joel Slemrod, a University of Michigan tax economist, told CalMatters he was wary of drawing the line straight from Europe.
I wouldn’t jump from the evidence we have to California.
Mr. Slemrod said the European taxes had much lower rates, were meant to be permanent and were not earmarked. Those differences point both ways for Prop. 40. A one-time tax gives less reason to move for good than an annual one. A 5% rate, about four times Norway’s top rate, gives more reason to move.
Weighing the claims
Measured against the record, the opponents’ strongest claim holds in part. The departures before Jan. 1 were real, concentrated at the very top and expensive: two men accounted for about a quarter of the projected haul. The 10% avoidance allowance could not absorb a loss that size, and the authors’ own base has moved by more than $300 billion in revisions as residency questions were settled.
The claim that the tax already loses money rests on weaker ground. It depends on treating lost income tax as permanent and growing, on Hoover’s higher estimate of what billionaires pay and on a court-survival discount that no judge has yet tested. In a March 4 response, Mr. Galle, Mr. Gamage, Mr. Saez and Mr. Shanske argued that Hoover’s elasticity implies a revenue-maximizing annual wealth tax rate near 10%. They also disputed Hoover’s central figure of $4.55 billion a year in billionaire income tax, putting it nearer $3 billion.
The supporters’ strongest claim also holds in part. Moving after Jan. 1 does not escape the tax unless a court says it does, and California residency law generally favors the state. The 25-year arithmetic, though, answers a different question from the one on the ballot. It sets lost income tax against the full $100 billion, and that $100 billion assumes the residency rule survives intact.
On Reddit, a reader in r/California_Politics who summarized the five tax measures for others described Prop. 40 in a line close to how its opponents frame it.
40: start taxing property retroactively?
That summary is half right. The measure excludes directly held real estate, so it does not tax property in the sense most homeowners mean, though it does reach stocks, private companies, art and other personal property. The valuation date, Dec. 31, comes after the vote. Only the residency date reaches back. That distinction is what the court fight will turn on, and Prop. 42 would settle it by banning retroactive taxes outright. Kayla Kitson, a tax policy analyst at the California Budget & Policy Center, a left-leaning research group, said that ban could take away the state’s ability to stop people from dodging a tax they see coming, CalMatters reported.
The ballot math
Prop. 40 qualified on June 17 with 980,438 valid signatures, NBC News reported, after talks to keep it off the ballot stalled before a June 25 deadline. To take effect, it has to beat both of its rivals. Building a Better California, the committee Mr. Brin funds, placed two countermeasures on the ballot. Prop. 41 would bring new taxes adopted after the start of 2026 under the state’s 1979 spending limit, which Prop. 40 is written to sidestep. Prop. 42 would ban new state taxes on personal property and retroactive taxes. If either gets more yes votes than Prop. 40, the wealth tax is blocked, CalMatters reported.
Voters back all three. A Public Policy Institute of California survey taken Sept. 4 to 10 found 52% of likely voters for Prop. 40, 51% for Prop. 41 and 54% for Prop. 42. “I don’t think that people at this point realize they’re direct countermeasures,” said Mark Baldassare, the institute’s survey director. The Berkeley Institute of Governmental Studies poll showed Prop. 40 ahead 52% to 33% in March and 48% to 41% in August, and its September poll showed a three-point lead. Since 2000, about a third of tax propositions have passed in California.
The money runs about six to one. Mr. Brin has put more than $138 million into the opposition, including the countermeasures, and opponents have raised more than $205 million, CalMatters reported. Supporters, mainly the union, have raised about $31 million. Mr. Brin could owe about $13 billion if the tax takes effect. Opposition ads call the measure a Trojan horse for broader taxes, a claim fact-checkers found only partly true.

Mr. Newsom and both candidates to succeed him, the Democrat Xavier Becerra and the Republican Steve Hilton, oppose the measure. The California Democratic Party, Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Ro Khanna support it. On Sept. 19, six Nobel laureates in economics, Daron Acemoglu, Abhijit Banerjee, Peter Diamond, Esther Duflo, Paul Krugman and Joseph Stiglitz, signed a letter saying a yes vote in California “will kickstart a movement” to tax the ultra-rich elsewhere.
What comes next
Ballots must be postmarked by Nov. 3 and received by Nov. 10, according to the secretary of state. If Prop. 40 passes and outpolls both countermeasures, the Franchise Tax Board would have about six months to build a system for valuing stocks, private companies, art and collectibles. Andrew LePage, a spokesman for the board, would not estimate how many staff members it would need. Net worth would be fixed on Dec. 31, and payments could be spread over five years at a higher total cost.
The lawsuits would come quickly, and Mr. Feldhammer expects his clients to be well armed.
These are people who have oftentimes plenty of wealth to spend on legal fees to put up the best defense money can buy.
Mr. Walczak argues that if courts find the residency rule impermissibly retroactive, they cannot rewrite it, which would leave California with departures and litigation but no revenue. The drafters say courts have rejected those arguments for a century. If the tax survives, the first installments are due with returns in April 2027.

