Federal agents arrested a Los Angeles-area server dealer on Oct. 1 on charges that he smuggled more than $300 million in computer servers built around Nvidia chips to China, routing them through Malaysia and Singapore, where they could be shipped without a U.S. license, the Justice Department said.

The man, Greg Lui, 38, of San Gabriel, Calif., is the latest of at least 20 people charged in the United States, Singapore and Taiwan since February 2025 with moving restricted American A.I. hardware toward China. Prosecutors in those cases have described more than $3 billion in server deals run through shell buyers. In the largest, against a co-founder of the server maker Supermicro, they say $510 million of a $2.5 billion order went on to China.

Those are the schemes investigators caught, and estimates of what they missed run much higher. Epoch AI, a research group, calculated in April that chips smuggled into China through 2025 added up to about 660,000 Nvidia H100 equivalents, roughly a third of the country’s A.I. computing power. Nvidia says less than half of 1 percent of its products have been diverted. Set against the record, the controls leak but still bind. Enforcement mostly reaches schemes long after the chips are gone, and the largest legal way around the rules, renting chips that sit in Southeast Asian data centers, is still open. But China’s own chipmakers still cannot meet domestic demand, which is why smuggling pays. Nvidia, meanwhile, has lost a market it once dominated.

The Earthmade case

Mr. Lui ran Earthmade Computer Inc., a closely held company in City of Industry that was incorporated on Nov. 10, 2023, Quartz reported. Prosecutors described it as an authorized distributor of Supermicro systems built on Nvidia processors. According to the 22-page indictment, Earthmade ordered servers containing Nvidia’s A100 and H100 chips, along with GeForce RTX 4090 and 5090 graphics cards, from American manufacturers. Prosecutors said Mr. Lui told those suppliers that the hardware would not end up in China.

In January 2024, Mr. Lui submitted a purchase order for 27 servers, part of a 70-server deal, at a cost of $7,614,000, and shipped them from Los Angeles to Kuala Lumpur with a packing list that marked them as export controlled, according to the Justice Department. Two months later, a co-conspirator told a Malaysian government official that all 27 had been transshipped to a buyer in China.

Another 92 servers flew from San Francisco International Airport to Kuala Lumpur, and the paperwork for the next leg, to Hong Kong, named a Chinese customer as the consignee, The Register reported, citing the indictment. The F.B.I. said those chips ended up with a company in Hangzhou. For a third order, 100 servers with H100 chips worth more than $22 million, prosecutors said Mr. Lui used documents from a fake buyer, a California company called Topmost, whose chief executive was listed as “Jackie Lui.” Topmost had been registered by the chief technology officer of one of the Malaysian freight companies. In 2021, the indictment says, Mr. Lui bought another person’s identity documents and used them to do business for the scheme.

Between January and October 2024, Earthmade received more than $176 million from two Malaysia-based shipping companies, prosecutors said. Business Insider put the figure at more than $180 million. The government wants to seize the proceeds, which it traced through Mr. Lui’s accounts at Bank of America and JPMorgan. The documents give different timelines. The Justice Department’s release describes conduct in 2023 and 2024, while the indictment, as quoted by The Register, says the scheme ran from around October 2023 until at least Aug. 12.

Mr. Lui faces three counts: conspiracy to violate the Export Control Reform Act and the Export Administration Regulations, outbound smuggling and conspiracy to commit money laundering, which carry maximum sentences of 20, 10 and 20 years. He has not entered a plea, and it was not clear on Friday whether he had a lawyer. John A. Eisenberg, the assistant attorney general for national security, announced the case using the administration’s new name for artificial intelligence, “super intelligence,” which he called “the defining technology of the era.”

The National Security Division will protect the American advantage in the chips that power this technology, a product of our unparalleled innovation and hard work, from illegal diversion by our economic and military adversaries.

John A. Eisenberg, assistant attorney general for national security, theregister.com

Roman Rozhavsky, an assistant director of the F.B.I.’s counterintelligence and espionage division, said Mr. Lui “allegedly sold the Chinese government hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of American Super Intelligence technology.” The release did not name Nvidia. In a statement, Nvidia said the case showed “yet again that smuggling is a losing proposition — legally, economically and technically.”

How the route works

Under the rules in force, an exporter needed a Commerce Department license to send advanced Nvidia chips to China but not to Malaysia or Singapore. The Biden administration’s last chip rule, issued in January 2025, would have capped shipments to most of the world, both countries included. The Trump administration rescinded it before it took effect in May 2025.

Singapore’s role showed up in Nvidia’s own books. In its annual report for the year ended January 2025, the company said Singapore accounted for 18 percent of its revenue by customer billing location, or about $23.7 billion, but less than 2 percent by shipments. “Customers use Singapore to centralize invoicing while our products are almost always shipped elsewhere,” the filing said.

Malaysia shows up in trade data. Its imports of graphics processors hit a record $2.74 billion in April 2025, TrendForce reported, and in the first four months of that year they passed the total for all of 2024. In an analysis published in September, Epoch found that China recorded $3.8 billion in server imports from Malaysia between April 2024 and June 2025, against $0.6 billion in matching exports on Malaysia’s books. The two countries counted about the same number of machines but valued them differently: roughly $106,000 a server in China’s figures and about $17,000 in Malaysia’s. The flow fell off after July 14, 2025, when Malaysia began requiring a permit to export, transship or move high-performance American A.I. chips through the country.

As checks have tightened, the schemes have grown more elaborate. In June, Malaysian customs officers at Kuala Lumpur’s airport stopped 72 servers with A.I. chips worth $13 million that had been declared as computer parts, The Next Web reported. In the Supermicro case, prosecutors in Manhattan said the defendants staged “dummy” servers for auditors, and a surveillance image showed a woman using a hair dryer to peel serial-number stickers off server boxes. In Taiwan, 130 servers with Nvidia’s B300 chips were shipped under one scheme. Customs stopped 56, and 74 reached China, PBS NewsHour reported.

Nvidia's AI Chips Reach China Despite US Curbs
A Bloomberg video report, published this week, on U.S. officials’ questions about why Nvidia missed red flags as its chips kept reaching China. Video: Bloomberg Television · YouTube

Bloomberg’s investigation, published Oct. 1 and drawn from conversations with dozens of people in five countries, set out warning signs that officials say Nvidia should have caught. In the Taiwan case, the F.B.I. said, Nvidia and Supermicro approved sales to a facility “clearly insufficient to house all the ordered servers.” In Thailand, a small data center bought chips in bulk using fake leases. OBON, a Bangkok company, bought servers for about 100 megawatts of capacity in a country with only a few hundred megawatts of A.I. data centers running, Bloomberg reported in May. Alibaba, named as one suspected end customer, said it had no business ties with Supermicro, OBON or the brokers in the case. Megaspeed, a Singapore company spun off from a Chinese gaming firm, imported at least $4.6 billion in Nvidia hardware, about 136,000 chips, from 2023 through November 2025, while Nvidia’s site visits found a few thousand, according to Bloomberg. Megaspeed denies wrongdoing.

“I’ve never felt like we got a straight answer as to how it’s possible for so many chips to be going to the Southeast Asia region if they were not serving customers in China,” Daniel Remler, a former head of A.I. policy at the State Department, told Bloomberg. Nvidia has not been accused of breaking export rules. Bloomberg reported that it dropped more than half of its previously authorized Asian buyers after tightening its whitelist, but a spokesman said it would keep selling to Megaspeed until ordered to stop. “When the law is clear, American companies honor US laws as they are, not as America’s critics wish they were,” he said. On oversized orders, he said that “a startup’s growth plan in a friendly nation is an opportunity for America, not a ‘red flag’ to be feared.”

Four years of rules

The restrictions began with a letter. On Aug. 26, 2022, the government told Nvidia that it needed a license to sell the A100 and the coming H100 in China. On Oct. 7 that year, the Commerce Department made it a general rule, saying it would restrict China’s ability “to both purchase and manufacture certain high-end chips used in military applications.”

Nvidia responded with the A800 and H800, versions with slower chip-to-chip links designed to fall below the limits. In October 2023, the department dropped the interconnect test that had let them through, extended the controls to 43 more countries and swept in the RTX 4090, the gaming card listed in Mr. Lui’s indictment. Earthmade was incorporated weeks later. The controls now reach retail counters too: Micro Center makes some RTX 5090 buyers sign a no-export pledge.

The Trump administration has moved in both directions. On April 9, 2025, it required a license even for the H20, a chip Nvidia had designed for China under the old limits, and Nvidia took a $4.5 billion charge. In December 2025, it agreed to let Nvidia sell the more powerful H200 in China, with the government taking 25 percent, and a rule in January made that formal. By May, licenses covered 10 Chinese companies. Beijing has steered its companies toward domestic chips, though, and H200 shipments came to less than 1 percent of Nvidia’s data center revenue in the quarter that ended in July, The Register reported. China has been weighing whether to let ByteDance and Alibaba import Nvidia chips by the million.

Prosecutions followed. In February 2025, Singapore charged three men with fraud over server deals worth about $390 million, which authorities said moved through Malaysia and possibly on to China. In December 2025, federal prosecutors in Houston announced Operation Gatekeeper, which they said involved at least $160 million in H100 and H200 chips and produced the first conviction for what they called A.I. diversion. In March, prosecutors in Manhattan charged Yih-Shyan Liaw, a Supermicro co-founder, and two others in the $2.5 billion case. Supermicro’s shares fell more than 33 percent the next day. Mr. Liaw has pleaded not guilty.

Super Micro Co-Founder Charged With Smuggling Chips to China | Bloomberg Businessweek
Bloomberg’s March report on the U.S. charges against Supermicro co-founder Yih-Shyan Liaw over servers diverted to China. Video: Bloomberg Podcasts · YouTube

In July, Singapore police froze a bungalow worth about $42 million, The South China Morning Post reported. Prosecutors there say Alan Wei, the chief executive of the Aperia group in the 2025 case, bought it with criminal proceeds, and he has pleaded not guilty. On Aug. 24, prosecutors in Keelung, Taiwan, indicted nine people, among them an Nvidia distribution manager and two Supermicro sales managers. Neither company was charged.

How much gets through

No one can count smuggled chips directly. In June 2025, Erich Grunewald and Tim Fist of the Center for a New American Security estimated that somewhere between 10,000 and several hundred thousand A.I. chips reached China illegally in 2024, with a median of about 140,000. They built the model from known cases and from listings on Chinese online marketplaces.

Epoch’s April report, by Isabel Juniewicz, put the 2024 figure at 159,000 H100 equivalents and the 2025 figure at 480,000. Its cumulative median was about 660,000, with a 90 percent range of 294,000 to 1.59 million. That median, the report said, “would be roughly a third of China’s total compute.” Allegations already on the record came to nearly 300,000 H100 equivalents, and the model assumes that investigators find about a quarter of what moves.

Because much smuggling goes undetected, the true total is likely higher.

Isabel Juniewicz, senior researcher at Epoch AI, epoch.ai

Ms. Juniewicz also warned that some allegations may be false and that not every attempted diversion succeeds. Last year, Bloomberg reported that operators in China’s western deserts planned data centers for 115,000 restricted Nvidia processors, a plan Nvidia and many officials called unrealistic at the time. U.S. officials now believe China has smuggled in at least that much computing power, the news service reported this week. The research firm SemiAnalysis, comparing production with installation data, estimated that hundreds of thousands of A.I. chips have slipped through, according to Bloomberg.

Nvidia disputes the scale. A spokesman told Bloomberg that U.S. prosecutors allege “less than one half of one percent of Nvidia products have been diverted.” He said the volume was immaterial when Chinese chipmakers are expected to produce about 2 million processors this year.

Governments and media have found insignificant diversion of controlled US products ... a drop in the bucket compared to the ocean of domestic compute China already has.

Nvidia spokesperson, to Bloomberg, arstechnica.com

The two sides are measuring different things. Nvidia’s figure covers what prosecutors have alleged, the part already caught. Epoch’s model assumes most smuggling is never caught, and its own range spans a factor of more than five. Mr. Fist, now director of emerging technology at the Institute for Progress, posted in May about a report that claimed much larger leakage.

If true, the facts alleged here are pretty damning for NVIDIA. Claims from the report:

- While NVIDIA claims that its compute revenues from China have dropped to zero, over 20% of its FY2026 AI compute revenue was driven by China, both through illegal chip smuggling and the use…

Tim Fist @fiiiiiist on X · May 13, 2026

The report’s central claim, that more than 20 percent of Nvidia’s A.I. compute revenue in its 2026 fiscal year came from China through smuggling and Southeast Asian intermediaries, could not be independently verified. Mr. Fist himself qualified it with “if true.”

The case against the controls

Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s chief executive, has made the commercial case for years. “We went from 95% market share to 0%,” he said at a Citadel Securities event in October 2025, Tom’s Hardware reported. China had been 20 to 25 percent of Nvidia’s data center revenue. In April, on a podcast from the Special Competitive Studies Project, he said that giving up a market the size of China had “already largely backfired.”

Rodrigo Balbontin of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, a Washington think tank, estimated in an October 2025 report that restrictions aimed at Huawei cost American companies at least $33 billion in sales from 2021 to 2024.

Sanctioning Huawei and attempting to cripple the company has proven to be hubristic and self-defeating

Rodrigo Balbontin, Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, itif.org

Huawei now claims the lead in China. Eric Xu, its rotating chairman, said last week that its Ascend chips had overtaken Nvidia’s share there, though he conceded that “it’s pretty hard to collect data about the market share of Nvidia in China,” The Register reported. Bernstein estimates that Nvidia’s share of China’s A.I. chip market will fall to about 8 percent this year, from roughly 66 percent in 2024. Mr. Xu said in September that Huawei could not make enough computing equipment to meet Chinese demand.

Readers saw Nvidia’s earlier assurances differently. On Reddit’s r/technology forum, one commenter answered the news of Mr. Lui’s arrest with sarcasm aimed at Mr. Huang.

But jensen huang said smuggling gpus to china was impossible and no nvidia high end gpus were going there!

u/JTibbs on r/technology

The record is close but not exact. Mr. Huang did not call smuggling impossible. He said that “there’s no evidence of any AI chip diversion,” a line Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts quoted in a June 1 letter asking whether Nvidia’s public statements were accurate. She invited him to testify, and he declined, offering a visit to Nvidia’s headquarters instead. “If Mr. Huang has time to attend a $1 million-a-head dinner at Mar-a-Lago and fly across the world to meet with President Xi Jinping of China, he should be able to find time to answer questions from Congress,” Ms. Warren said.

Supporters of the controls read the same numbers the other way. Chris McGuire, a senior fellow for China and emerging technologies at the Council on Foreign Relations, estimated in December 2025 that even under aggressive assumptions Huawei would produce only about 5 percent of Nvidia’s total A.I. computing power in 2025, falling to 4 percent this year and 2 percent in 2027. He wrote that TSMC had illicitly made nearly three million Ascend chip dies for Huawei in 2023 and 2024.

Huawei is not a threat that justifies loosening controls; it is evidence that the controls are working.

Chris McGuire, senior fellow, Council on Foreign Relations, cfr.org

The economist Noah Smith wrote in January that the controls are “not killing China’s chip industry, but they’re slowing it down in important ways.” Liang Wenfeng, the founder of DeepSeek, made a similar point from the other side in a 2024 interview cited by Foreign Policy: “Money has never been the problem for us. Bans on shipments of advanced chips are the problem.” Taken together, the best evidence from each camp holds up. Nvidia has lost the Chinese market, and Huawei has gained from that loss. China is still short of chips, which is the shortage the controls were designed to create. If Epoch’s median is right, a third of China’s compute arrived illegally. That is a large leak, and it also shows how much Chinese buyers want what the rules deny them.

The rental route

On Oct. 1, the Financial Times reported that Tencent had signed a five-year lease worth about $7 billion for access to roughly 100,000 advanced A.I. chips in Oracle data centers in Southeast Asia. Oracle has not confirmed the deal.

On Reddit, one reader argued that Mr. Lui had simply chosen the wrong method.

Rookie mistake. Just build the compute out in Dubai and in Malaysia (like Oracle has done) and rent that to the export-controlled mainland Chinese firms.

u/AbeFromanEast on r/technology

Renting is outside the current rules because the chip never leaves the data center. ByteDance, Alibaba, Tencent and Moonshot AI have reportedly used restricted Nvidia hardware this way through facilities in Thailand, Malaysia and elsewhere, CNBC reported in August.

Another commenter in the same thread went further and suggested that the gap might be deliberate.

It actually very explicitly doesn’t. The BIS has repeatedly confirmed that export controls apply to hardware, and renting access to GB300s or whatnot to China don’t violate export controls.

u/goldcakes on r/technology

The substance holds up. A Baker McKenzie lawyer told The Information that export-control lawyers widely accept that the Commerce Department cannot enforce a remote-access rule under current law. That is why the House voted 369 to 22 on Jan. 12 to pass the Remote Access Security Act, which would let the department treat remote access to controlled chips as an export. “The CCP’s AI ambitions are being fueled by its access to American chips housed in data centers located outside of China,” said Representative John Moolenaar, the Michigan Republican who leads the House select committee on China. The Senate has not passed the bill. It could not be verified that the Bureau of Industry and Security has “repeatedly confirmed” the point, and the commenter’s reasons for the gap are opinion.

What enforcement looks like

The Bureau of Industry and Security, the Commerce Department agency that enforces the rules, had 12 export control officers posted abroad when it made its 2026 budget request. Singapore was its only post in Southeast Asia. The bureau asked for $303 million, up from $171 million, partly to raise the number of officers abroad to 30. Its request for 2027 seeks $450 million and 40 more officers overseas. In the 2025 fiscal year, the bureau completed 1,840 end-use checks in 73 countries, according to its annual report.

The money is lopsided. The 2025 CNAS report found that profits from three reported smuggling cases, about $140 million, were more than double the bureau’s annual enforcement budget of $55 million.

Congress has turned to the chips themselves. The Chip Security Act, sponsored by Representative Bill Huizenga, a Michigan Republican, would require exporters to verify where advanced A.I. chips are and to report credible signs of diversion. The House Foreign Affairs Committee passed it 42 to 0 on March 26, a week after the Supermicro indictment. Mr. McGuire posted the result.

The Chip Security Act was approved unanimously by the House Foreign Affairs Committee, 42-0. This is the second overwhelming, bipartisan vote within HFAC to strengthen export controls on AI chips, after AI Overwatch passed 44-2. Congress is speaking loudly and clearly on this.

Chris McGuire @ChrisRMcGuire on X · March 26, 2026

In September, researchers at Georgetown’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology estimated that a ping-based location check, which times signals to confirm where a chip is, would cost about $3.1 million to $28.8 million a year if the servers were owned. They called the diversion of A.I. chips “indisputable.” In July, the bill was added to the Senate’s version of the annual defense bill. Industry groups including the Semiconductor Industry Association had called its tracking requirements “burdensome” in 2025.

Some readers doubted that enforcement would ever reach the industry’s largest companies. On Reddit, one wrote of Earthmade:

Small company with undisclosed number of employees, would never happen to one of the big boys.

u/GroundbreakingPage41 on r/technology

The record points both ways. A Supermicro co-founder and board member was indicted in March, and Taiwan has charged an Nvidia manager. But no chipmaker has been charged as a company, and Nvidia has not been accused of wrongdoing. Nor has the government put Megaspeed on any restricted list, and Nvidia still sells to it.

What comes next

The fight now runs through the defense bill. Nvidia and AMD have asked the White House to keep the AI Overwatch Act, which would give Congress more say over chip export licenses, out of the final version, Politico reported last week. They also want the Chip Security Act changed so that it would not require hardware changes and would allow more time to comply. The companies argue that broad restrictions push China to build its own chips. House and Senate negotiators have not released a final text.

The Commerce Department is drafting a rule that would require data center operators in countries such as Thailand and Singapore to block remote access by Chinese companies, The Information reported in August. Nvidia plans to start shipping its RTX PRO 5500 processors to China in late December at roughly 500,000 a quarter, The Information has also reported.

Mr. Lui’s case, United States v. Lui, No. 2:26-cr-00618, is in federal court in Los Angeles. Prosecutors want him held without bail until trial as a flight risk, Bloomberg reported.