Fifty years ago today, in the early hours of November 16, 1976, Andy Puopolo was stabbed in the chest on a street in Boston’s Combat Zone. He was a Harvard senior and a starting cornerback, and he hoped to go to medical school. He died on December 17 after 31 days in a coma, the Harvard Crimson has recounted. For the anniversary, Danny McDonald of the Boston Globe went back to the case and to the family, who say plainly that half a century has not dulled anything.

“I always had the anger,” said Fran Puopolo Sciaba, Andy’s older sister. “I still have the anger.”

The night itself is chaotic, and parts of it are still disputed. Members of the Harvard football team went out together after the season. Two prostitutes approached the equipment van that was supposed to take the players back to Cambridge, and one of them stole a wallet from it. There was a chase, then a standoff. One Harvard player was stabbed and survived. A fight broke out in the street, Puopolo went in to help a teammate who was being beaten, and Leon Easterling drove a knife into his chest.

Easterling, Edward Soares and Richard Allen were charged. All three are now dead, as are many of the people who were directly involved. Puopolo was Italian American, from the North End, and the three defendants were Black. The killing came during the years of court-ordered busing, when the city was dealing with urban violence and racial tension was close to boiling over. So the case became a public argument about race. That produced an enormous amount of coverage, at least one book, and a legal fight that eventually reached the US Supreme Court.

A vintage woodcut depicts a football helmet on a wooden chair beside rows of empty seats along a brick-lined street.

The family says race never had anything to do with the wrong done to Andy. If the three defendants had been Italian guys from the North End, they told the Globe, they would have wanted exactly the same thing: justice for Andy. In their view, all the attention on the racial politics of the moment pulled focus from the one thing that mattered.

Two trials, two theories

It helps to understand how the first trial worked. Prosecutors relied on joint enterprise, a doctrine that lets several people be convicted of the same crime if they took part in a criminal venture together. Under that theory it doesn’t matter whose hand held the knife. If you were in on the venture, you are responsible for its results. In 1977 the first jury convicted all three men of first-degree murder.

The convictions did not last, because of how the jury had been picked. During jury selection each side gets a set number of peremptory challenges, which let it strike prospective jurors without giving a reason. In this case, 12 of the 13 potential Black jurors were kept off the jury. In Commonwealth v. Soares, decided in 1979, Massachusetts’ Supreme Judicial Court ruled that systematically excluding jurors by race through peremptory challenges violated the defendants’ right to a fair trial, and it overturned the verdicts.

“If nothing else, it changed the law in Massachusetts that a prosecutor or defense could use race to systematically exclude one class of people,” said Henry F. Owens III, who represented Allen. “In that regard, it changed the law.” The Puopolos, along with one lawyer who worked for the prosecution, note that defense lawyers also struck jurors with Italian surnames. According to the Globe, the case influenced Batson v. Kentucky, the 1986 decision in which the US Supreme Court held that excluding jurors because of their race is unconstitutional.

A woodcut-style illustration shows light and dark human figures separated by wooden barriers, with three dark figures standing outside near a broken opening.

The family says a prosecutor had warned them that Andy would be a “sacrificial lamb,” used to keep the city’s racial tensions under control. That is how the second trial felt to them. The retrial began in October 1979. This time Allen and Soares were acquitted outright, and Easterling, who held the knife, was convicted of manslaughter rather than murder. In his later appeal, Easterling testified that when he stabbed each of the two students, he was stepping into a fight on Soares’s behalf because he thought Soares was outnumbered.

Owens still believes the second jury got it right. “My client was just there and being present during a crime is not a crime,” he told the Globe. “He was just standing around.” That one sentence captures the gap between the two trials. The first jury accepted that all three men were in it together. The second jury saw at least two of them as bystanders. The Puopolos believe all three should have been held accountable, and they have never accepted the second version.

“It failed us,” said Fran, a retired teacher and occupational therapist who lives in Westwood. The family was naive, she said, to trust that the criminal justice system would work for them. Danny Puopolo, now close to 70, manages the loading docks at the Hynes Convention Center. He admits that after the second verdict he thought about taking justice into his own hands. He decided he didn’t want to lose his soul. He still regrets that the family never got an apology.

“The rage,” he said. “The rage is awful.” And: “I envy the people who can forgive the people who do nasty things to their family. I envy them because I wish I could do it.”

Two hands grip a tangled mass of thorny vines with one red leaf, while sunlight streams through a window near a vase of wilted flowers.

What changed, and what didn’t

The city changed. According to Jan Brogan’s book The Combat Zone, at one point in the 1970s the red-light district had a dozen strip clubs and roughly three dozen adult entertainment businesses. Downtown Boston has two today. Political, economic and technological pressures all contributed, and the decline took years. But people who watched it happen trace the beginning to Puopolo’s death. “It absolutely killed the Combat Zone,” said Tom Carey, who worked on the appeal for the Suffolk district attorney’s office.

There is now a waterfront park in the North End named for Andy, along with scholarships in his name at Boston Latin and at Harvard. His family remembers his dry wit, his sympathy for the underdog, and how much the injustices he came across bothered him. Danny, who calls his brother the best human being he ever knew, still prays for him. Fran says she still asks Andy for help when she’s stressed. Their mother, Helen, is 98 and still lives in the house the family moved into when Andy was a teenager. Danny says she won’t leave, partly because it was the last place Andy lived, and she still feels him there.

The family has gone over the what-ifs a million times. Danny wonders whether Andy would have stayed out of the chaos if his little brother had been there that night and Andy had been busy keeping him safe. “You just don’t know,” he said. Fran has run Andy’s photo through AI to see what he would look like at 70.

In the end the case produced a precedent and a cleaned-up downtown. The family is left with a computer’s guess at the older man Andy never got to become. “It’s 50 years later,” Danny said, “and I think about all we missed.”